Outside Employment and Security Clearances

Our DC-Metropolitan Based Law Firm Specializes in Employment, Security Clearance, and Retirement Law.

Federal employees are often subject to strict guidelines regarding outside employment, particularly when it comes to maintaining a security clearance. While outside employment can be an important source of income and professional development, it can also present significant risks for Outside employmentfederal employees, especially those holding sensitive positions. Engaging in certain types of outside employment or business activities may raise concerns regarding conflicts of interest, loyalty, or national security, potentially leading to disciplinary action or even the loss of security clearance.

The Risks of Outside Employment for Federal Employees

Outside employment can present risks to federal employees, particularly those holding security clearances. When engaging in outside work, federal employees must ensure that their activities do not conflict with their primary duties, create ethical concerns, or jeopardize their security clearance. Several factors can raise red flags when it comes to outside employment, including:

  1. Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest arises when an employee’s outside employment interferes with their official duties or compromises their impartiality in performing government work. For example, if a federal employee works for a private company that does business with the government or competes with their agency, it may create a situation where the employee’s judgment could be compromised. The Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch (5 C.F.R. Part 2635) set forth by the Office of Government Ethics (OGE) prohibit federal employees from participating in matters where they have a financial interest or outside employment that conflicts with their official duties. Concerns in this area can lead to both security clearance and disciplinary concerns.

  1. National Security Concerns

For employees holding a security clearance, outside employment in areas related to national security, foreign governments, or private entities with sensitive business interests may raise national security concerns. This is particularly relevant for employees working in defense, intelligence, or law enforcement. For example:

  • Foreign Influence: If an employee holds outside employment with a foreign government or company, there may be concerns about the employee’s loyalty to the U.S. government, and whether they could be influenced or coerced by foreign entities.
  • Exposure to Sensitive Information: Federal employees working in jobs that involve classified information must be cautious about inadvertently sharing sensitive details with outside employers, even in unrelated fields.
  • Foreign Financial Interests: Employees with outside business ventures in countries that may pose a national security risk could be perceived as vulnerable to exploitation or bribery.
  1. Time and Commitment Conflicts

Another concern for federal employees engaging in outside employment is whether it interferes with their primary duties. Federal employees are generally expected to devote their full attention to their government responsibilities, and outside employment that interferes with their job performance may lead to disciplinary action. For employees with security clearances, any appearance of negligence or divided loyalty can be problematic.

The Security Clearance Review Process: How Outside Employment Is Considered

Outisde employment can come up during the security clearance process at various times such as when an initial application for a clearance is submitted, during a reinvestigation, or based on the notification of a concern regarding outside employment by an Agency.

When determining whether a federal employee’s outside employment activities will affect their security clearance, the government looks at several factors. The Adjudicative Guidelines for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Information provide a framework for evaluating the security risks associated with outside activities. There are several security guidelines that may be at issue based on outside employment. Specifically, the guidelines under Guideline B (Foreign Influence), Guideline E (Personal Conduct), and Guideline L (Outside Activities) all may pose an issue for a clearance holder engaged in outside employment.

Factors Considered in the Security Clearance Process:

  • Financial Interests: Whether the outside employment involves financial interests that conflict with the employee’s government position or present a risk of bribery or exploitation.
  • Foreign Connections: Any financial, business, or familial connections to foreign governments or entities that could pose a conflict of interest or lead to susceptibility to foreign influence.
  • Proper Disclosure: A failure to properly disclose outside employment to an Agency and during the clearance process can lead to security concerns about the outside activity and the individual’s integrity and trustworthiness. Proactive disclosure of such information can be afforded mitigating value during a security review of such outside employment.

Steps Federal Employees Can Take to Protect Their Security Clearance

Federal employees must be proactive when it comes to outside employment and take steps to ensure their security clearance remains intact. Here are some best practices for navigating outside employment without jeopardizing your security clearance:

  1. Seek Approval from Your Agency

Before engaging in outside employment, federal employees must often seek prior approval from their agency’s ethics office or security office. Many agencies require employees to submit a Request for Approval of Outside Employment (often as part of an annual financial disclosure process) to ensure there are no conflicts of interest or security concerns. Agencies may approve or deny outside employment based on the potential risks to national security or other ethical considerations.

Even if the outside job seems unrelated to the employee’s government duties, it is important to disclose it to avoid later complications. This step ensures transparency and can protect the employee if their outside employment is ever questioned.

  1. Review Agency Guidelines and Ethics Rules

Employees should familiarize themselves with their agency’s policies on outside employment. Federal agencies often have specific guidelines that govern permissible outside activities and require employees to adhere to ethical conduct standards. Understanding these rules can help prevent inadvertent violations that may affect their clearance.

  1. Avoid Conflicts of Interest

Federal employees must avoid engaging in outside employment that could create a conflict of interest with their official duties. This includes working for companies that do business with the government, having financial interests in entities that are regulated by the employee’s agency, or accepting positions that could impair the employee’s impartiality. Employees should also be cautious when engaging in business ventures or outside employment in industries that could pose national security risks, such as defense contracting or intelligence.

  1. Consider Consulting Legal Counsel

Given the complexity of rules surrounding outside employment and security clearances, it may be wise for federal employees to seek legal counsel before accepting outside employment. An attorney with experience in federal employment law or security clearance law can offer guidance on potential risks, assist with disclosure processes, and help craft a strategy to address any concerns raised by outside activities.

Other Consequences of Violating Outside Employment Rules

Failing to comply with agency guidelines regarding outside employment can lead to other severe consequences beyond security clearance actions. The most likely other consequence would be disciplinary action, including suspension, demotion, or termination, depending on the severity of the violation. While outside employment can provide federal employees with valuable opportunities, it comes with inherent risks, especially for those holding security clearances. Federal employees must be vigilant and aware of the potential for conflicts of interest and national security concerns. By seeking approval for outside employment, adhering to ethical guidelines, and consulting with legal counsel when necessary, federal employees can reduce the likelihood of disciplinary action and protect their security clearance from being jeopardized.

Contact Us

Berry & Berry, PLLC advises and represents individuals on issues involving the proper completion and submission of security clearance applications, background investigations, security clearance denials and revocations, and federal employee disciplinary matters.  Please contact the firm at (703) 668-0070 or www.berrylegal.com to schedule an initial consultation with an experienced attorney who is familiar with the security clearance and disciplinary process.

Alcohol security clearance

One of the more frequent issues that arises in the context of security clearance investigations involves alcohol abuse or over-consumption of alcohol by federal employees, military employees and government contractors.  This is regulated by Adjudicative Guideline G for those holding or seeking a security clearance. This article discusses the issues that many individuals face with respect to alcohol and their security clearance.

Alcohol Abuse or Overconsumption by Cleared Employees or Applicants

Alcohol over-consumption and abuse can be a major factor in maintaining or obtain a security clearance. Security concerns regarding this issue arise under Adjudicative Guideline G, Alcohol Consumption of Security Executive Agency Directive (SEAD) 4. Adjudicative Guideline G is the section of the Guidelines which involve a clearance holder or applicant’s use of alcohol and it’s impact on an individual’s ability to obtain or maintain a security clearance.

Guideline G issues usually come into play when a federal employee, military employee or government contractor have issues regarding the use of alcohol. The most obvious issue that begins this type of review is a recent alcohol-related traffic concern such as a DUI or other intoxication charge. If recent, these charges tend to require more investigation prior to the issuance of a security clearance or may require a clearance review.  The clear concern for federal agencies that evaluate security clearances is that excessive alcohol consumption can lead to the use of questionable judgment or the failure to control impulses, both of which are not considered acceptable for purposes of access to classified information.

Security Concerns Raised by Alcohol Abuse or Consumption

When issues arise involving alcohol abuse or over-consumption, in the scope of a security clearance investigation or review, it is very important to take them seriously and to obtain legal representation experienced with these types of issues in order to minimize the potential damage to a security clearance or otherwise mitigate the security concerns. When alcohol issues are reviewed in regards to security clearances cases, they fall under Guideline G, Alcohol Consumption, SEAD 4, which reads as follows:

Guideline G: 
Alcohol Consumption under SEAD 4

The Concern. Excessive alcohol consumption often leads to the exercise of questionable judgment or the failure to control impulses, and can raise questions about an individual’s reliability and trustworthiness.

Conditions that could raise a security concern and may be disqualifying include:

(a) alcohol-related incidents away from work, such as driving while under the influence, fighting, child or spouse abuse, disturbing the peace, or other incidents of concern, regardless of the frequency of the individual’s alcohol use or whether the individual has been diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;

(b) alcohol-related incidents at work, such as reporting for work or duty in an intoxicated or impaired condition, drinking on the job, or jeopardizing the welfare and safety of others, regardless of whether the individual is diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;

(c) habitual or binge consumption of alcohol to the point of impaired judgment, regardless of whether the individual is diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;

(d) diagnosis by a duly qualified medical or mental health professional (e.g., physician, clinical psychologist, psychiatrist, or licensed clinical social worker) of alcohol use disorder;

(e) the failure to follow treatment advice once diagnosed;

(f) alcohol consumption, which is not in accordance with treatment recommendations, after a diagnosis of alcohol use disorder; and

(g) failure to follow any court order regarding alcohol education, evaluation, treatment, or abstinence.

Conditions that could mitigate security concerns include:

Under Paragraph 23 of SEAD 4, there are 4 mitigating factors provided to mitigate security concerns involving alcohol abuse.  These are:

23. Conditions that could mitigate security concerns include:

(a) so much time has passed, or the behavior was so infrequent, or it happened under such unusual circumstances that it is unlikely to recur or does not cast doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or judgment;

(b) the individual acknowledges his or her pattern of maladaptive alcohol use, provides evidence of actions taken to overcome this problem, and has demonstrated a clear and established pattern of modified consumption or abstinence in accordance with treatment recommendations;

(c) the individual is participating in counseling or a treatment program, has no previous history of treatment and relapse, and is making satisfactory progress in a treatment program; and

(d) the individual has successfully completed a treatment program along with any required aftercare, and has demonstrated a clear and established pattern of modified consumption or abstinence in accordance with treatment recommendations.

While many of the same principles have applied to alcohol usage cases under Guideline G in the past adjudicative guidelines, SEAD 4 recently changed some of the concerns and factors slightly as of June 8, 2017, so it is important to be familiar with them. The following case is a sample of the types of decisions made by security clearance adjudicators involving alcohol from March, 2023. Sample DOHA Case (Applicant was denied a clearance where he had not acknowledged that he had an alcohol problem, and continued to consume alcohol with regularity despite being advised during his treatment in 2013 to abstain. He was also not participating in treatment or attending AA).

Case Examples Involving Guideline G Cases where Clearance Was Denied 

The following are 3 examples where individuals clearances were denied and 3 examples where the individual’s clearance was granted under Guideline G.

Example A:  Security clearance applicant was convicted 3 times of Driving under the Influence of Alcohol (DUI) between a period of 8 years.  The last alcohol-related DUI was 2 years prior to the Statement of Reasons being issued with response to Guideline G. He had recently began to abstain from consuming alcohol, but not enough time has passed to conclude alcohol is no longer a problem. Applicant’s security clearance was denied.

Example B:  Security clearance applicant had a long history of alcohol abuse from 1991 to 2012 and was diagnosed with alcohol dependence. The applicant had participated several times in both inpatient and outpatient treatment programs, but had relapsed. He was alcohol free for 14 months prior to the hearing. The Administrative Judge found that his current period of sobriety was not sufficient to mitigate the security concerns under Guideline G, alcohol consumption. Applicant’s security clearance was denied.

Example C: While security clearance applicant had no alcohol-related incidents since 2014 (and the hearing was held in May of 2016) and had remained sober for more than a year still resulted in a denial of the security clearance by the Administrative Judge. On appeal, the DOHA Appeal Board found that the recency factor alone does not compel an Administrative Judge to make a favorable clearance decision. The Appeal Board held that it has never established a “bright line” rule as to the recency of conduct raising security concerns. The extent to which security concerns have become mitigated through the passage of time or recency is instead a question that must be resolved based on the evidence as a whole. As a result of these findings, the Applicant’s security clearance was denied.

Case Examples Involving Guideline G Cases where Clearance Was Granted

Example A:  Security clearance applicant was 34 years old and had a history of alcohol-related incidents before being diagnosed with alcohol dependence in 2006. Following alcohol treatment in 2006, he abstained from alcohol consumption for 5 years before resuming infrequent use. The applicant was found to have recommitted himself to total abstinence, was found to attend Alcoholics Anonymous, and had a sponsor to help him work on alcohol issues. Applicant was found to have mitigated the security concerns under Guideline G, alcohol consumption and his security clearance was granted.

Example B: Security clearance applicant was 54 years old and had 3 alcohol-related incidents from 1984 to 2000. Following that time period, he had abstained from alcohol use from 2001 to 2009, a period of about 8 years. Subsequently, he had resumed responsible alcohol use without any problems, consisting of 1-2 beers after work, but not daily. Further, there was no evidence of any alcohol-related incident for the past 15 years. The Administrative Judge found that the individual had provided sufficient evidence to mitigate the security concerns under Guideline G and granted the security clearance.

Example C: Security clearance applicant was 45 years old and had issues with alcohol dependence over his life. Applicant was found to have taken seriously the fact that he was an alcoholic and had to completely abstain from alcohol. The individual also presented evidence that he regularly attended Alcoholics Anonymous and also that he had a strong support network. The Administrative Judge found that the applicant was earnest in his efforts at recovery and had mitigated the security concerns under Guideline G, alcohol consumption and granted the individual’s security clearance.

Things to Consider for Alcohol Cases Under Guideline G

In security clearance cases involving Guideline G, Alcohol Consumption, it is very important to understand just how important it is to demonstrate that the individual understands and acknowledges (where appropriate) their alcohol issues and concerns.  Denying a known alcohol problem only makes mitigation more problematic. It cannot be overstated that security clearance adjudicators take alcohol concerns seriously. Absent significant evidence of rehabilitation or other efforts, it can be hard to keep or obtain a security clearance.

14 Considerations in Alcohol Cases

Here are 14 items (not a full list, which is too long to list here) that we often consider when handling Guideline G cases:

  1. How long ago was the last problem with alcohol use?
  2. How many incidents of alcohol abuse or alcohol-related traffic incidents are there?
  3. Has there been medical intervention?
  4. Has there been any alcohol treatment given or taken?  Was such treatment voluntary or mandatory (i.e. part of a court resolution).
  5. Is it important to get an independent review by a physician regarding the likelihood of recurrence of alcohol issues? An expert physician may be needed.
  6. Has their been abstinence from alcohol (and for how long)?
  7. Has their been a change in alcohol usage?
  8. Who could potentially testify positively about the applicant’s alcohol usage and changed behavior?
  9. What kind of documentation can be used for exhibits to show abstinence from alcohol?
  10. What kind of documentation can be used to show a change in behavior and more limited alcohol usage?
  11. What types of organizations (Alcoholics Anonymous, Church, Treatment Programs, Physicians, other groups) can be used to support the applicant’s case?
  12. What types of evidence can be used to show how serious the applicant takes the alcohol use issues? i.e. letters of support, character letters, etc.
  13. Is a letter of proposed revocation of a security clearance appropriate to add as an exhibit should the alcohol issues recur.
  14. Is there medical or treatment documentation available to potentially use as exhibits during the clearance proceedings?

Alcohol consumption security clearance cases under Guideline G can involve many differing types of variables and a number of mitigating factors specific to each case so hiring experienced counsel to represent and advise the individual involved is critical because each case is different. The key for such security clearance proceedings in this type of case is to be prepared.

Contact Us

When facing alcohol-related or other security clearance issues, it is very important to have an experienced security clearance lawyer. If you need assistance with a security clearance case, please call us at (703) 668-0070 or contact us at www.berrylegal.com.

Review of Formal Complaint After SubmissionFederal Employee EEO process

After it is submitted, the Agency will begin to review the grounds of the EEO complaint. The Agency will then either accept the claims for investigation or dismiss some or all of them based on procedural grounds. In accepting claims, the Agency will send you an acceptance letter listing the claims to be investigated. In the letter, the Agency will spell out the next steps in the EEO process. The letter will also state that the investigation must be completed within 180 days. 

It is important to have federal employee EEO legal representation in these cases.

Dismissal of Claims

If the Agency dismisses all or a part of a complaint, the federal employee has options.
 If the Agency dismisses the EEO complaint, it must issue a final decision. The Agency should clearly set forth the reasons for dismissing the complaint. The Agency will provide the complainant appeal rights to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) where an appeal can be filed.

Acceptance of Claims and Investigation

If the Agency accepts a claim, it will initiate an investigation into the EEO complaint. An investigator will be appointed. These investigators can be in house federal employees or government contractors. Typically, the appointed investigator will contact you and ask you to provide some responses to questions about your EEO complaint. The investigator may also ask for documents or other supporting materials for your complaint.

What Does the Investigator Do?

Once the investigator is appointed, they are authorized to conduct the EEO investigation for the Agency. Investigators are authorized to administer oaths. In conducting their investigations, investigators use many different methods to conduct the investigation. These include affidavits, interviews, interrogatories or other methods to obtain facts about the EEO complaint.

The investigator will also ask for this type of information from others named in the Complaint or who are witnesses. The Agency will then conduct this investigation into the claim(s) and issue a Report of Investigation. This will be issued approximately 180 days after the formal complaint was filed. Federal Employee EEO investigations can include a variety of methods such as interviews, requests for responses to questions, and/or affidavits. The process varies by Agency and investigator. The investigative process is considered to be non-adversarial and often conducted by a third party contract investigator.

Rebuttals

In some cases, after the Complainant’s statement and responsive statements are taken, the investigator will want a rebuttal statement. This is just a statement responding to the information that was provided by one of the witnesses in the case.

Completion of Investigation Process

Federal agencies are required to complete an investigation within 180 days of the filing of a formal complaint. If the complaint is amended or consolidated with another complaint, the investigation must be completed 180 days after the filing of the last complaint or no later than 360 days after the filing of the original complaint, whichever is earlier.

Contact Us

Our law firm represents and advises federal employees in EEO complaint investigations. If you need legal assistance regarding an EEO complaint or other employment matter, please contact our office at (703) 668-0070 or at www.berrylegal.com to schedule a consultation.

On January 20, 2025, President Trump issued a Presidential Memorandum (PM) directing federal agencies to, as soon as practicable, take all necessary steps to terminate remote work arrangements and require employees to return to work in person at their respective duty stations on a full-time basis, provided that the department and agency heads shall make exemptions they deem necessary. On January 22, 2025, more detailed guidance was provided on the Return to Office through the Office of Personnel Management. The OPM guidance instructs agencies to revise their telework policies to require employees to work full time at their respective duty stations, unless excused from this requirement based on disability, qualifying medical condition, or other compelling reason certified by the agency head and the employee’s supervisor. OPM’s guidance recommends that agencies be in full compliance with the PM within 30 days.

Things to Keep in Mind

Communicate with Leadership

One of the first key things to keep in mind with the Return to Office order is to maintain open lines of communication with your supervisors and leadership. Every employee’s circumstances will be different and making sure to keep your supervisor and leadership informed of your specific situation and any barriers you may have for a Return to Office may help down the road in trying to obtain an exception to the requirement. Such exceptions will need to be based on compelling reasons and be approved by the employee’s supervisor and agency head. It is not yet clear what will qualify as compelling reasons, but one example that has been discussed pertains to military spouses who work remotely. It is likely that there will be other exceptions as well.

Medical Conditions, Disability, and Reasonable Accommodation

The OPM guidance instructs that employees can be excused from the Return to Work order based on disability or qualifying medical condition. For employees who already have such conditions on file with their agency and are working with Reasonable Accommodations in place, employees should make sure that these accommodations address telework or remote work to ensure that they remain in place as the Return to Office process unfolds. For those employees who have a disability or qualifying medical condition, but do not have a reasonable accommodation in place yet, the employees should work quickly to initiate those requests to seek accommodations that will address their specific conditions and needs. The Rehabilitation Act still protects reasonable accommodations that can include telework.

Union-Related Issues 

Some employees who are members of bargaining units within federal agencies may be covered by previously negotiated collective bargaining agreements that address remote work and telework. Currently, it appears that OPM will not interfere with those agreements. However, it is likely that efforts may be taken to change those agreements. Such efforts will take time to unfold but employees should remain aware of their Union’s activities in this regard. Furthermore, the likelihood of litigation over many of these return to work orders by national unions remains high.

Avoidance of Discipline

Once deadlines are established for Return to Office, employees who fail to do so and are not on approved reasonable accommodations or who do not have an exemption based on compelling reason could run into disciplinary issues for failure to follow directives. In the event that such discipline is issued, employees should be cognizant of their rights to respond to such disciplinary actions and challenge those actions through established procedures.

Deferred Resignation

Federal employees were recently notified, on January 28, 2025, of an option for a deferred resignation. The deferred resignation instructs employees to make an election by February 6, 2025, and will theoretically provide employees with leave pay until September 30, 2025. For those employees who cannot physically return to the office, this may seem like a reasonable alternative. However, federal employees should be cautious of this program and seek legal advice before making any such election. The legal basis for the program is not clearly established which may subject the program to legal challenge. There is also the potential that the deadline could be extended or curtailed. It is just too soon to tell.

The program’s email also fails to provide much-needed clarity around how the program would be implemented, whether administrative leave would be utilized, who would be required to continue working, and how an election may impact an employee’s ability to transfer to a different position. Due to these various unknowns, employees should speak with experienced legal counsel before electing to participate.

Contact Us

It is important for a federal employee with telework issues or considering the deferred resignation issues to speak with counsel. Berry & Berry, PLLC represents federal employees in these types of federal employment issues and can be contacted at (703) 668-0070 or www.berrylegal.com to arrange for an initial consultation regarding these or other federal employment issues.

Merit Systems Protection Board Online Appeals

The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) recently overhauled its electronic appeal system, e-Appeal. The new system is now the only way to electronically file MSPB cases as of October 2023. When pursuing a case before the MSPB, it is therefore important for a federal employee to understand the latest procedures for filing an appeal and accessing case records. The only alternative to filing online this way is to rely on physical mail, which can be slower, and which carries the risk of important documents getting lost in the mail. As a result, it is generally a good idea to use the e-Appeal system for an MSPB appeal as it is faster and more reliable.  It is also required for appellant attorney representatives to register as e-filers, meaning only self-represented (pro se) filers may rely solely on physical mail if desired.

Background for the Changes

In short, the old e-Appeal system was two decades old and needed revamping. Users could only access one case at a time, and overall, the system was clunkier and harder to use than it needed to be. As a result, the MSPB developed a better, newer e-Appeal portal and launched it in late 2023. While it is not perfect, it is a significant improvement upon the old system. The MSPB’s e-filing regulations were updated for the new system, and they are located at 5 C.F.R. § 1201.14.

Basics for Filing an E-Appeal

The basic procedures for filing an appeal have not changed much, but there are a few things that are still very important to keep in mind. Likely the most important aspect to understand is that an appeal and any supporting documents you may want to include—must be timely filed. This generally means filing within 30 days of the action that is being appealed. Exceptions or extensions for time to file can be made in unusual circumstances, but it is never a good idea to rely on such a request being granted, especially when a request is made close to or after the normal deadline has passed. For e-filing, technical issues with the e-Appeal system can also be grounds for extension of filing time under certain circumstances, but it is always a good idea to file with extra time to spare just in case you run into technical issues.

Filing the MSPB Online Appeal 

Filing an appeal on the e-Appeal system is fairly straightforward. The portal takes you through all the necessary steps to obtain the necessary information and allows you to include supplemental documents. While the process is designed to be accessible to individuals representing themselves, there are a few parts of the e-Appeal filing process where legal advice is necessary. For instance, there is a section that asks for details about the basis of your appeal. Here, it is usually a good idea to include at least a summary of your legal arguments for the appeal. The Form 185 summarizes the types of arguments or claims that may be applicable, but these can be more complex than they seem. So, it is generally a great idea to consult with an attorney as early as possible, so that you do not lose the opportunity to raise important arguments.

Two-Factor Authentication for MSPB Appeals 

The e-Appeal system uses email-based two-factor authentication (2FA) for added security. Once you register as an e-filer and begin working on a draft appeal, the system first presents you with important information about timeliness of filing, limitations on the MSPB’s jurisdiction, and similar preliminary items. Then, although there can be a lot of information to fill out, there are only three basic stages of drafting the appeal: “Appellant and Agency Information,” “Agency Action” (i.e., what happened that you are appealing), and “Representation” (i.e., whether you are pro se or designating a representative).

Note that if an attorney or other representative submits the form from their account on your behalf, you will have to separately register as an e-filer yourself and connect your account to the case—otherwise, case documents will be mailed to you even if your representative is a registered e-filer.

E-Appeal vs. Uploading a Completed Form 185: What’s the Difference?

When using the e-Appeal system, you can also upload a separately-completed PDF of Form 185 after filling out the webform, or you can just fill out the information requested by the portal. The portal essentially walks you through Form 185 and puts it together for you at the end. If you do both, your Initial Appeal document will appear to be a doubled copy, but that is not a problem—and in some cases it may be easier to format certain fields as desired, complete the Designation of Representative portion, or perform other actions on a PDF copy of the form that you can then upload. Either way, it is important to ensure all necessary information is included somewhere.

Effect of E-Filing an Appeal

The main reason to e-file an MSPB case is because, in addition to being the preferred system, you will then receive (and can file) all case documents electronically via the portal, with email notifications of new filings. As such, you will be informed of the latest developments in your case as soon as there is a new document available, and you can therefore react accordingly and plan your next steps as quickly as possible rather than waiting to learn of developments in the mail. Once your case is filed, the rest of the case’s filings will generally take place via electronic submissions to the portal by all parties. Additionally, the portal allows an e-filer to see the full case record, general case information including agency representative contact information, a list of pleadings you have submitted, and a “Case Associations” tab that shows any connected or otherwise related cases.

Caveats to E-Filing

While the e-Appeal system has many advantages to the alternative method of paper filings, there are a few potential pitfalls to watch out for. For example, you are still required to stay up to date on the electronic docket. This includes making sure that your email’s spam filter is not blocking notification of new submissions in the case. Similarly, you must keep your contact information up to date with any changes. There are also a few special categories of pleadings or other types of filings that cannot be completed on the e-Appeal portal. Additionally, you cannot file something with sensitive or classified information, you cannot serve a witness with a subpoena using the system, and you cannot request a case to be treated as a class (group) appeal via the electronic system. There are special rules that must be followed for these and other special types of filings.

Regarding the timeliness of filings, the rules may seem a bit inconsistent and there are also some exceptions. Generally, the system will stamp pleadings with the submission time in Eastern time, regardless of where the filer uploads it from—but the actual timeliness does depend where the filer uploads it from. (This default may be further modified if an Administrative Judge states, for example, that they will consider the timeliness of filings based on their own time zone and not the filer’s).

Conclusion

While the MSPB e-Appeal system is intended to be accessible regardless of whether you are represented, there are a variety of nuances and considerations for e-filing, between filing the appeal itself and proceeding with the case. Because of the often convoluted legal and procedural issues that may arise in the MSPB process, and because every case is different, it is a good idea to consult with legal counsel regarding this area of law and how best to pursue your situation and issues. MSPB online appeals are an important part of the appeals process.

If you are a federal employee seeking representation before the MSPB, you can contact us via our website, www.berrylegal.com, or by phone at (703) 668-0070, to arrange an individual consultation. We also maintain an MSPB-specific legal blog covering similar types of legal and practical issues.

Representing Current and Federal Employees in OPM Disability Reconsideration Appeals for Over 25 Years

Our federal retirement lawyers represent current and former federal employees nationwide seeking reconsideration following a disability retirement denial by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM). We represent federal employees in their retirement matters before their federal agencies and OPM. It is common for many current and former federal employees seek our legal assistance when OPM has issued a denial in their disability retirement application.  In such cases, the federal employee or retiree is provided with an opportunity to request reconsideration regarding OPM’s initial decision. Most disability retirement applicants do not realize that they may have a better chance of receiving disability retirement on reconsideration than in the initial application.

Understanding the OPM Reconsideration Process

Reconsideration is simply OPM’s method of reviewing its initial denial to ensure that the applicable laws, rules and regulations have been properly applied to a federal employee or retiree’s application for disability retirement. However, in order for OPM to begin its review, the federal employee or retiree must initiate a request for reconsideration. The OPM reconsideration process will then afford the federal employee or retiree an early opportunity to address any deficiencies and legal errors in OPM’s initial decision.  It is often the case that OPM will spend more time and resources reviewing the reconsideration application than the initial retirement package.

Disability Retirement Application by Current or Former Federal Employee

For the OPM disability retirement process to start, the first step is to apply. A current federal employee or former federal employee (within a year of separation) may seek disability retirement from OPM. Once the application and supporting documentation is submitted to OPM, the decision process will begin.

Initial Denial from OPM

Before reconsideration can start, OPM must first deny the individual’s request for disability retirement. OPM’s denial is referred to as an initial decision. This usually comes in the form of a 5-8 page denial letter explaining why the disability retirement application was denied. Much of the initial decision will contain boilerplate language denying the request for disability retirement. There will, however, be a section dedicated to discussing the basis of the OPM denial. The letter will also discuss how their determinations are made, your rights for reconsideration and it will also include a CSA Number which you will have to reference should you decide to appeal. The initial decision will provide the various rights on reconsideration afforded federal employees and applicants.

Review OPM’s Basis of the Denial

As a general principle, it is important to carefully review the basis for the OPM denial prior to seeking reconsideration. The denial could be based on errors on the part of OPM or it might be based on the fact that the individual did not provide enough medical proof for disability retirement. It is fairly common for the basis of denial to be related to the clarity of the medical proof and medical statements provided to OPM. OPM has published guidance regarding some of the problems which occur in the processing of disability retirement applications regarding documentation.

Requesting Reconsideration from OPM

Generally, a federal employee has 30 days within which to request reconsideration from the date of an adverse OPM decision. The deadline is critical and does not involve significant work to initiate. The reconsideration request must be received within 30 days (not just placed in the mail). As a result, it is critical to ensure that the request to OPM is timely. Otherwise, the request for reconsideration can be denied by OPM as untimely. OPM’s Request for Reconsideration of Disability form is fairly straightforward and easy to complete. It is usually important to check the last box in which the federal employee requests an extra 30 days to provide additional information about an individual’s qualification for disability retirement. It is important to include the CSA number attached to the denial on the form. Once the OPM Request for Reconsideration form is received, assuming that the form is completed correctly, additional information will need to be gathered in support of overturning OPM’s initial decision within the 30-day window.

Filing the Additional Information Needed on Reconsideration

After the OPM disability retirement reconsideration process has begun, the next step will be to add additional documentation to prove that the OPM decision was incorrect. There is a right to request a copy of the claim file which will normally include the information that the individual submitted to OPM in making the first decision in the case. Requesting this information can be helpful to see whether or not OPM reviewed any other information in issuing the OPM denial. In other instances, the claim file is not as useful.

In seeking reconsideration, the more information provided to OPM, the better. Because you are seeking disability retirement, the additional documentation is likely to be medical. Some of the more common reconsideration responses include:

(1) Complete histories of the medical or disabling condition at issue;

(2) Findings from previous medical examinations;

(3) Other records of medical treatment; and

(4) Other evidence supporting the disability, such as personal statements and letters of support from family and friends.

Once received, the reconsideration file will be sent to a new OPM specialist on review who will review the new materials, along with the existing file, and issue a determination either approving the disability retirement application or issuing a new denial. Reconsideration specialists tend to give substantial weight to new medical documentation so this can often be a key part of the reconsideration process. We find that the reconsideration stage yields a more meaningful review of the disability retirement claims. We have also found that OPM reconsideration specialists are typically quicker in issuing a reconsideration decision than specialists during the initial application review.

Additional Appeals

If OPM denies reconsideration, other rights, such as pursuing the case before the Merit Systems Protection Board, are available. The reconsideration decision will typically provide full instructions on how to appeal the decision to the appropriate field office of the MSPB. Usually, an individual will have 30 days in which to file an MSPB appeal regarding their retirement denial with the MSPB. Again, timing is important and an individual can lose their rights if the appeal is not timely filed. Once submitted, an administrative judge will be assigned to oversee the hearing in the case. In an MSPB retirement appeal, having counsel is critical to potential success. An MSPB appeal is similar to the civil action process, with attorneys on both sides and a judge. The same procedures that apply in regular court apply in MSPB appeals. This link provides more information on MSPB retirement appeals.

Contact Us

When seeking reconsideration from OPM in a disability retirement application, it is important to obtain legal representation.  You can contact our law firm through www.berrylegal.com, or by telephone at (703) 668-0070, to schedule a consultation to discuss your individual federal employment retirement matter.

If you wish to explore legal representation, please call our office or use this form to inquire about our consultation process.

Call Us Today!703-668-0070

Office Location

Plaza America
11700 Plaza America Drive
Suite 305
Reston, VA 20190

Get Directions

Follow Us

  • twitter