
Security clearance cases involving Guideline E: Personal Conduct can be particularly serious because they often concern an applicant’s honesty, judgment, reliability, trustworthiness, or willingness to follow rules and regulations. Unlike some of the other adjudicative guidelines, Guideline E is broad enough to encompass many different types of conduct, including alleged falsification of security forms, lack of candor during an investigation, workplace misconduct, repeated rule violations, misuse of government resources, and other behavior that may raise questions about whether an individual can be trusted with classified or sensitive information.
Guideline E issues frequently arise during initial security clearance investigations, periodic or continuous vetting, clearance upgrades, and reviews of existing national security eligibility.
For individuals facing these concerns, the specific facts matter enormously. An allegation of misconduct does not automatically mean that a clearance will be denied or revoked. The government evaluates both the potentially disqualifying conduct and the circumstances that may explain, rebut, or mitigate it under the whole-person concept.
What Is Guideline E: Personal Conduct?
Guideline E is one of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines contained in Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4).
The central security concern is whether an individual’s conduct demonstrates questionable judgment, dishonesty, lack of candor, unreliability, or an unwillingness to comply with rules and regulations.
These concerns matter in the security clearance context because individuals entrusted with classified or sensitive information must be relied upon to provide truthful information and comply with security requirements.
Common Guideline E Security Clearance Issues
Guideline E can arise in many circumstances. Some of the most common cases involve the following.
Alleged Falsification or Omission on the SF-86 or Security Clearance Application
One of the most significant Guideline E allegations involves an accusation that an applicant deliberately omitted, concealed, or falsified information on an SF-86, NBIS eApp submission, personnel security questionnaire, employment document, or related government form.
Typical disputes may concern the failure to disclose:
- prior employment problems;
- disciplinary actions or terminations;
- arrests or criminal matters;
- drug involvement;
- financial problems;
- foreign contacts or interests;
- previous security clearance problems; or
- other information requested by the applicable questionnaire.
The critical issue in many of these cases is intent.
There can be an important difference between deliberately concealing information and making an innocent mistake, misunderstanding a question, forgetting information, or interpreting a question differently from an investigator or adjudicator.
For example, the fact that information was omitted from an SF-86 does not by itself answer the separate question of whether the omission was intentional. The applicant’s explanation, the wording of the question, prior disclosures, surrounding circumstances, subsequent corrections, and consistency of the applicant’s statements may all become important evidence.
Lack of Candor During a Background Investigation
Guideline E concerns are not limited to the information placed on a security questionnaire.
An applicant may also face allegations that he or she gave false, misleading, incomplete, or evasive information during an interview with an investigator, security official, adjudicator, employer, or other authorized government representative.
These cases can be especially difficult because investigators and adjudicators may compare statements made at different stages of the clearance process.
An inconsistency does not necessarily establish intentional dishonesty. Memory, misunderstanding, poorly phrased questions, passage of time, ambiguity, and differences in context can sometimes explain apparently inconsistent statements.
Nevertheless, unexplained inconsistencies can create significant credibility problems. A response to a Guideline E concern should therefore identify and reconcile material differences whenever possible rather than simply ignoring them.
Why Intent Matters in Falsification Cases
Intent is frequently one of the most important issues in a Guideline E falsification case.
If the government alleges a deliberate omission or false statement, an effective response should ordinarily address not merely whether the underlying information was incorrect, but why the incorrect answer was given.
Relevant evidence may include:
- what the applicant understood the question to mean;
- whether similar information was disclosed elsewhere;
- whether the applicant volunteered the information during an interview;
- whether the applicant attempted to correct the answer before being confronted;
- whether records available at the time were confusing or incomplete;
- how long ago the underlying event occurred;
- whether the applicant had difficulty remembering dates or details;
- whether the applicant sought guidance regarding how to answer the question; and
- whether the surrounding circumstances are consistent with intentional concealment.
A detailed explanation supported by documents is usually more persuasive than a conclusory statement that the applicant “did not intend to lie.”
Prompt Correction Is Important
SEAD 4 expressly recognizes mitigation when an individual makes prompt, good-faith efforts to correct an omission, concealment, or falsification before being confronted with the facts.
Timing therefore matters. This cannot be overstated.
Someone who independently realizes an answer was incorrect and promptly contacts the appropriate security official may be in a materially different position from someone who admits the information only after investigators produce contradictory evidence.
Applicants who discover an error on a security form should carefully evaluate the appropriate reporting or correction process rather than simply waiting to see whether the issue is discovered.
Guideline E Can and Does Overlap With Other Adjudicative Guidelines
Another important feature of Guideline E is its potential overlap with other security concerns.
For example, alleged drug use may principally implicate Guideline H, while a failure to disclose the drug use on an SF-86 may independently create Guideline E concern.
Similarly:
- criminal conduct may implicate Guideline J while concealment of the conduct raises Guideline E;
- financial problems may raise Guideline F while false statements about those problems create Guideline E concerns;
- foreign contacts may implicate Guideline B while deliberately concealing them may raise Guideline E; and
- alcohol-related misconduct may implicate Guideline G while inaccurate statements regarding the events may generate an additional Personal Conduct allegation.
This distinction is important because resolving the underlying conduct does not necessarily resolve a separate allegation that the applicant was dishonest about it.
Guideline E Mitigating Conditions
SEAD 4 contains several circumstances that may mitigate Personal Conduct concerns.
Among them are situations in which:
- the individual promptly and in good faith corrected an omission, concealment, or falsification before being confronted;
- a failure to cooperate or disclose information resulted substantially from advice by legal counsel or another professional responsible for advising the individual about the security process, followed by full cooperation once the requirement became clear;
- the conduct was minor, occurred long ago, was infrequent, or occurred under unusual circumstances and is unlikely to recur;
- the individual acknowledged the behavior and took counseling or other positive steps to address the circumstances contributing to it;
- the individual took steps to eliminate vulnerability to coercion, manipulation, or duress;
- the adverse information was unsubstantiated or came from a source of questionable reliability; or
- an association with persons involved in criminal activity was unwitting, has ended, or otherwise occurred under circumstances that do not raise doubts about the individual’s reliability, judgment, or willingness to follow rules.
Evidence That Can Help Mitigate a Guideline E Case
One of the most common mistakes in responding to a security clearance concern is submitting a lengthy explanation without supporting evidence.
Whenever possible, important factual statements should be corroborated with other evidence.. Depending on the allegations, useful evidence can include:
- contemporaneous emails and correspondence;
- personnel and employment records;
- SF-86 or prior security questionnaire submissions;
- investigative records;
- performance evaluations;
- awards and commendations;
- disciplinary records;
- training certificates;
- counseling or treatment documentation where relevant;
- records showing repayment or restitution;
- policies or instructions that clarify what the applicant was told;
- sworn declarations or affidavits;
- statements from witnesses with firsthand knowledge;
- character letters from supervisors and colleagues;
- evidence of successful subsequent employment;
- evidence of compliance with security requirements; and
- documentation showing corrective or rehabilitative measures.
The strongest evidence will depend on the particular allegation.
Common Mistakes in Guideline E Responses
Several recurring mistakes can make Personal Conduct cases more difficult when you respond to a Letter of Intent or Statement of Reasons.
Providing Only a General Denial
I don’t recommend general denials in security clearance responses. Every material allegation should generally be addressed specifically. We often see responses in cases that we have not handled that are very short or just state “deny” or “admit” without providing more information. These are generally not very helpful and can help to drag out the process.
Failing to Produce Supporting Evidence
A detailed narrative is important, but documentary evidence can substantially strengthen an individual’s case.
Ignoring Intent
In falsification cases, explaining what happened is not enough. The response should often explain why the evidence does or does not establish an intent to hide information.
Attacking Investigators or Former Employers
Challenging facts is far more effective than accusing or attacking an investigator or former employer. Often, attacking an investigator will hurt a case, n0t help it. Where a source is inaccurate or unreliable, explain why and present contradictory evidence.
Minimizing Clearly Established Conduct
Where misconduct did occur, acknowledging the conduct and demonstrating rehabilitation is often more effective than advancing an explanation inconsistent with objective records. Do not minimize misconduct that you will be admitting to. It is almost always not helpful.
Waiting Until an Appeal to Develop Evidence
Whenever possible, favorable evidence should be developed at the earliest meaningful stage of the adjudicative process. Oftentimes, waiting to include information until a final appeal can be too late. For example, some individuals seek to wait to provide additional information in Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals cases at the appeals stage (post-Administrative Judge). However, by the time you file with the DOHA Appeal Board, new evidence generally cannot be added.
Helpful Examples
Example 1: Workplace Misconduct and Terminations
Suppose an applicant receives a Guideline E allegation based on several former employers reporting repeated rule violations and terminations.
The response should examine each employment incident individually.
If one termination actually resulted from a reduction-in-force, another involved a disputed supervisor relationship, and only one involved substantiated misconduct, the evidence should make those distinctions clear.
Helpful documents might include personnel records, positive performance evaluations, emails, witness statements, grievance records, positive letters from former co-workers or supervisors and evidence showing several years of successful employment after the incidents.
The applicant should also address the government’s broader concern about whether the events demonstrate a continuing pattern of poor judgment.
Example 2: Alleged SF-86 Falsification
Assume an applicant failed to list an adverse employment event on a security questionnaire.
A strong response would examine the precise wording of the question, what the applicant understood at the time, whether the employment event actually fell within the scope of the question, what the applicant disclosed elsewhere, and whether the individual later volunteered or corrected the information.
Where applicable, contemporaneous documents can be critical in demonstrating that an omission resulted from confusion or mistake rather than an intent to conceal. It is also often the case that an individual who checked no in a box, discussed the underlying issue in the substantive comments on the SF-86.
Example 3: Misconduct Combined With a Candor Issue
Suppose an employee engaged in prohibited conduct, like the use of an illegal drug, but initially gave an incomplete explanation when questioned about it.
The government may raise both the original conduct under Guideline H and a separate Guideline E concern regarding candor.
The response should therefore address both issues. Even if the underlying misconduct can be mitigated because it was isolated and occurred years earlier, the applicant may still need to explain the later statement and demonstrate why it does not indicate continuing dishonesty or unreliability.
Example 4: False or Unreliable Allegations
Not every allegation contained in a clearance investigation is accurate.
Guideline E expressly permits consideration of whether adverse information is unsubstantiated or comes from a questionable source.
Where an allegation is false or exaggerated, it may be important to identify inconsistencies in the source’s account, contradictory documents, witnesses with firsthand knowledge, motives affecting the source’s reliability where legitimately supported, and objective records establishing what occurred.
The focus should remain on evidence rather than speculation about the source.
Reach out to a Security Clearance Lawyer if you Have Guideline E Issues
Guideline E is one of the broadest provisions of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines. It can encompass alleged dishonesty, lack of candor, rule violations, workplace misconduct, misuse of resources, questionable judgment, vulnerability to exploitation, and other conduct affecting an individual’s reliability or trustworthiness.
A Guideline E allegation, however, is not evaluated in isolation. Security clearance adjudicators consider the specific circumstances, the reliability of the evidence, the individual’s explanation, mitigating conditions, evidence of rehabilitation, the likelihood of recurrence, and the individual’s record as a whole.
For applicants and clearance holders facing a Letter of Intent, Statement of Reasons, proposed revocation, or other Guideline E concern, a comprehensive response supported by credible documentation can be critical. Berry & Berry, PLLC represents federal employees and government contractors in security clearance matters, including Guideline E Personal Conduct cases.
📞 Call us: (703) 668-0070
🌐 Visit: https://www.berrylegal.com
Security Clearance and Foreign Preference (Guideline C): What You Need to Know
For many security clearance applicants and holders, having connections to another country is simply part of modern life. Individuals may have been born overseas, possess dual citizenship, own property in another country, or have family members living abroad. These circumstances do not automatically prevent someone from obtaining or maintaining a security clearance. However, they can raise questions under Guideline C – Foreign Preference of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (Security Executive Agent Directive 4 or SEAD 4).

At Berry & Berry, PLLC, we regularly represent federal employees, military personnel, and government contractors facing security clearance issues involving foreign preference. One of the biggest misconceptions we encounter is that having foreign citizenship or overseas ties automatically disqualifies someone from holding a clearance. In reality, security clearance adjudicators focus on whether an individual’s actions demonstrate a preference for a foreign country over the interests of the United States.
This article explains how Guideline C works, what conduct may trigger a review, and how many cases can be successfully mitigated.
What Is Guideline C – Foreign Preference?
Guideline C addresses conduct that may indicate an individual has placed (or may place) the interests of another country ahead of those of the United States.
The government’s concern is not an individual’s heritage, ethnicity, or family background. Rather, adjudicators evaluate whether a person’s conduct demonstrates divided allegiance or raises concerns about their judgment, reliability, trustworthiness, or willingness to safeguard classified information.
Why Foreign Preference Matters in Security Clearance Cases
The security clearance process is designed to identify and manage national security risks, not to penalize individuals for having international backgrounds.
The key question is:
Have the individual’s actions demonstrated a preference for another nation over the United States?
Clearance adjudicators examine whether foreign citizenship or privileges have been exercised in a way that could call an individual’s allegiance into question.
Common Guideline C Issues
Several situations commonly trigger a Guideline C review during a background investigation:
- Exercising rights associated with foreign citizenship
- Voting in a foreign election
- Using a foreign passport after becoming eligible for a U.S. security clearance
- Accepting benefits that require an acknowledgment of allegiance to another country
- Serving in a foreign military or foreign militia
- Actively pursuing new foreign citizenship
- Accepting government privileges from another nation
Not every one of these circumstances will result in a clearance denial. However, each may require additional explanation and documentation.
Dual Citizenship Does Not Automatically Disqualify You
Perhaps the most common misconception surrounding Guideline C is that dual citizenship automatically prevents someone from obtaining or keeping a security clearance. That is incorrect.
Many individuals who possess U.S. security clearances also hold dual citizenship. The government generally focuses less on whether you have dual citizenship and more on how you exercise the rights that accompany it.
For example, adjudicators may scrutinize:
- Continued use of a foreign passport
- Voting in foreign elections
- Accepting free health benefits tied to foreign citizenship
- Previous employment for a foreign country
- Taking actions that affirm allegiance to another nation
By contrast, simply acquiring dual citizenship at birth because of your parents or birthplace is often viewed much differently.
Guideline C vs. Guideline B: Understanding the Difference
Many applicants confuse Guideline C (Foreign Preference) with Guideline B (Foreign Influence).
Although they frequently arise together, they address different concerns.
Guideline B – Foreign Influence
Focuses on outside pressures that may affect an individual, including:
- Family members overseas
- Foreign financial interests
- Business relationships
- Close foreign contacts
The concern is whether another country could potentially influence or coerce the applicant.
Guideline C – Foreign Preference
Focuses on the applicant’s own conduct.
The government evaluates whether an individual has voluntarily taken actions suggesting a preference for another country’s interests over those of the United States.
Understanding this distinction is important because different legal standards and mitigation strategies apply.
How to Mitigate Guideline C Concerns
The good news is that many Guideline C issues are fully mitigable.
Security clearance adjudicators understand that international ties are increasingly common in today’s global society.
Some of the most important mitigating factors include:
- Dual citizenship resulted solely from birth or family circumstances.
- Foreign citizenship does not conflict with U.S. national security interests.
- Foreign rights or privileges were exercised before becoming a U.S. citizen.
- The individual is willing to renounce foreign citizenship if necessary to protect U.S. national security interests.
- The exercise of foreign citizenship presents little or no security risk.
Each case is unique, and mitigation depends on the specific facts involved.
The Importance of Honesty During the Clearance Process
One of the most significant mistakes applicants make is attempting to minimize or conceal foreign ties.
Security clearance investigators routinely verify:
- Foreign travel
- Citizenship records
- Passport usage
- Overseas property ownership
- Foreign family relationships
Attempting to hide these issues often creates Guideline E (Personal Conduct) concerns that can be more damaging than the underlying Guideline C issue.
Being truthful, complete, and cooperative throughout the investigation is often one of the strongest mitigating factors available.
Real-World Examples of Guideline C Issues
While every case is different, Guideline C issues commonly arise when applicants:
- Continue using a foreign passport after obtaining U.S. citizenship.
- Voting in foreign elections while holding a security clearance.
- Accept government benefits requiring allegiance to another country.
- Maintain dual citizenship without understanding how exercising certain rights could affect their clearance.
In many of these situations, favorable outcomes are possible when applicants demonstrate loyalty to the United States and provide appropriate mitigating evidence.
How We Can Help
At Berry & Berry, PLLC, we understand that foreign preference cases often involve complicated legal and personal circumstances.
Our attorneys help clients:
- Respond to Statements of Reasons (SORs)
- Prepare mitigation evidence
- Navigate security clearance hearings
- Appeal adverse clearance decisions
- Develop legal strategies tailored to Guideline C allegations
Whether you are applying for your first clearance or defending an existing one, early legal guidance can make a significant difference.
Contact an Experienced Security Clearance Lawyer
If you are facing a Guideline C – Foreign Preference issue, don’t wait until your clearance is denied before seeking legal advice.
Berry & Berry, PLLC represents federal employees, military members, intelligence professionals, and government contractors throughout the security clearance process.
📞 Call: (703) 668-0070
🌐 Visit: https://www.berrylegal.com
The earlier you address potential concerns, the better positioned you may be to protect your career and your security clearance.
Security clearance issues involving sexual behavior (Guideline D) are among the most sensitive and misunderstood concerns faced by federal employees, military personnel, and government contractors. While deeply personal, these matters can have serious implications for your ability to obtain or maintain a security clearance.

At Berry & Berry, PLLC, we regularly represent individuals navigating these complex situations with professionalism. This guide explains how Guideline D works, what adjudicators look for, and how concerns can be mitigated.
What Is Guideline D – Sexual Behavior?
Guideline D is part of the Adjudicative Guidelines under Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4). It addresses situations where sexual behavior may raise concerns about an individual’s:
- Judgment
- Reliability
- Trustworthiness
- Susceptibility to coercion or blackmail
As outlined in SEAD 4:
Sexual behavior is a concern when it involves criminal activity, poor judgment, or creates vulnerability to coercion, exploitation, or duress.
Importantly, sexual orientation alone is never a basis for denial. The government is focused on risk, not identity.
Why Sexual Behavior Matters in Security Clearance Cases
Security clearance determinations are fundamentally about risk management. Adjudicators are not moral arbiters, they assess whether your conduct could:
- Expose you to blackmail or coercion
- Reflect poor decision-making
- Indicate dishonesty or lack of candor
- Violate laws or regulations
Even private conduct can become relevant if it creates security vulnerabilities.
Common Sexual Behavior Issues That Trigger Clearance Concerns
While every case is unique, some recurring issues include:
- Undisclosed extramarital affairs
- Solicitation or payment for prostitution
- Viewing or possession of illegal pornography
- Inappropriate workplace conduct
- Secretive or undisclosed relationships
- Online sexual behavior (including messaging or content sharing)
These issues may arise during:
- Background investigations
- Polygraph examinations
- Self-reporting requirements
- Workplace complaints or incidents
Because these matters are highly personal, we approach every case with discretion, confidentiality, and empathy.
How Security Clearance Adjudicators Evaluate Sexual Behavior
Adjudicators look at the “whole person concept”, meaning they evaluate:
- The nature and seriousness of the conduct
- Frequency and recency
- Whether the behavior was voluntary or coerced
- Whether it was disclosed honestly
- Evidence of rehabilitation or change
The key question is not simply what happened, but:
👉 Does this behavior still pose a security risk today?
How to Mitigate Sexual Behavior Security Clearance Concerns
The good news is that many Guideline D cases are successfully mitigated. The goal is to demonstrate that the concern:
- Is no longer ongoing
- Does not reflect your current judgment
- Cannot be used to coerce or exploit you
Common Mitigation Strategies
Depending on the situation, mitigation may include:
- Demonstrating the conduct was isolated or occurred long ago
- Showing transparency (e.g., disclosure to spouse or employer)
- Providing evidence of counseling or treatment
- Obtaining evaluations from mental health professionals
- Proving there is no risk of blackmail or coercion
- Submitting character references and supporting documentation
For example:
- In extramarital affair cases, disclosure and counseling may help
- In prostitution-related cases, rehabilitation and time since the conduct are key
- In online conduct cases, demonstrating changed behavior and accountability is critical
Official Mitigating Factors Under SEAD 4
SEAD 4 provides specific mitigating conditions that may apply:
- The behavior occurred during adolescence and did not continue
- The conduct is remote in time or unlikely to recur
- The individual is not vulnerable to coercion or exploitation
- The behavior was private, consensual, and discreet
- The individual has completed or is engaged in treatment with a favorable prognosis
These factors are often central to building a successful defense.
Real Case Examples from the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA)
Understanding how these cases are decided can be helpful. Here are a few real-world examples:
❌ Clearance Denied
- Individual paid for prostitution multiple times over decades, including while holding a clearance
- Insufficient evidence of rehabilitation
- Subject to coercion because spouse is unaware
- Ongoing concerns about judgment
✅ Clearance Granted
- One-time solicitation of prostitution
- Immediate disclosure to employer
- Strong evidence of rehabilitation and good character
✅ Clearance Granted
- Accidental download of illegal content many years prior
- No pattern of behavior
- Successfully mitigated under other guidelines
❌ Clearance Denied
- Attempted non-consensual workplace misconduct
- Lack of mitigation and poor judgment
These cases show that context, honesty, and rehabilitation matter greatly.
The Importance of Honesty and Early Legal Guidance
One of the biggest mistakes individuals make is:
❌ Failing to disclose conduct
❌ Minimizing or misrepresenting facts
❌ Waiting too long to seek legal help
In many cases, the cover-up is worse than the conduct itself.
Working with an experienced security clearance attorney early in the process can significantly improve your outcome.
How We Can Help
At Berry & Berry, PLLC we understand how difficult and personal these cases can be. We provide:
- Confidential, judgment-free legal advice
- Strategic guidance tailored to your situation
- Representation in responding to the Statement of Reasons
- Representation in security clearance hearings and appeals
- Assistance with mitigation evidence and documentation
We have helped many clients retain or obtain their security clearances, even in challenging cases involving Guideline D.
Contact a Security Clearance Lawyer Today
If you are facing a security clearance issue involving sexual behavior, it is critical to act quickly and strategically. Early intervention can make a significant difference in protecting your career and clearance. Sexual behavior concerns under Guideline D are highly personal, but they are also legally manageable in many cases. With the right approach, documentation, and legal strategy, many individuals are able to successfully mitigate these concerns.
📞 Call us: (703) 668-0070
🌐 Visit: https://www.berrylegal.com
If you are a government contractor or federal employee facing an adverse security clearance decision by the National Security Agency (NSA) — including denial, revocation, or loss of Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) access — you need experienced legal representation to protect your career and reputation. You need an experienced NSA security clearance lawyer.

NSA Security Clearance Appeals — Legal Help for Contractors & Employees
At Berry & Berry, PLLC, our security clearance attorneys help contractors and NSA federal employees appeal NSA security clearance decisions and navigate the complex NSA appeals process with confidence. We frequently represent individuals in security clearance appeals before the NSA. The NSA is part of the Intelligence Community group of agencies and have a unique security clearance appeals process.
Why Appeal an NSA Security Clearance Decision?
A security clearance denial or revocation can disrupt your employment, contract eligibility, and future job prospects in national security, defense contracting, and intelligence roles. The NSA has its own clearance process and standards under Executive Order 12968 and Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4) — meaning appeals must be precisely prepared and timely.
Failing to respond correctly, or missing strict deadlines, can result in a final decision that leaves you without a security clearance and without options for months or longer.
Of note, there are some changes in the NSA security clearance appeals process that have been implemented. We explain the current process below.
NSA Security Clearance Appeal Process — Step by Step
The NSA security clearance appeal process moves quickly and requires strategic preparation. The following is the process followed for government contractors. NSA federal employees have a slightly different process.
1. NSA Issues a Statement of Reasons/Clearance Decision Statement
When an individual has a security clearance or SCI access denial or revocation from the NSA (referred to as the Statement of Reasons (SOR)), it will list the security concerns at issue under SEAD 4. In addition, the NSA will typically provide what they believe to be the most pertinent documents from the Investigative File. Keep in mind that the NSA will have other documents, including a transcript of any polygraph examinations, on hand but likely will not provide these. They often provide a summary report.
For NSA security clearance cases, individuals with unresolved security concerns will receive a Statement of Reasons (SOR). Under this process, the individual will usually have 10 days to elect to appeal a denial and notify the agency about whether or not a Personal Appearance is being requested. It is important to request a Personal Appearance, along with submitting a written appeal. This deadline for electing these options is strict. Individuals in this process will have the ability to request an abbreviated Personal Appearance of no more than 30 minutes in-person in addition to submitting their written review.
There is ongoing discussion about transition to a virtual platform for the PA process, but they are often held onsite. You usually have 30 days to submit your written response to the NSA when notified of your SOR, but they often add time if the receipt occurred after the date of the SOR (which is in most cases). If you have elected an in-person meeting that will take place at the NSA after the written response is received. You may have counsel represent you in this process. Having an experienced security clearance lawyer is important in the NSA process to protect a contractor’s rights.
2. Contractor Response to the NSA SOR
If the individual elects to reply to the SOR they will need to respond to the NSA’s security concerns by written submission. A thorough response must be prepared to address all of the security issues. It is critical to also provide exhibits, such as relevant evidence, declarations, character letters, declarations, affidavits, and other documentation related to the NSA’s security concerns or the character of the individual. It is also important to address mitigation and the Whole-Person Concept.
Our security clearance lawyers typically represent individuals starting with this first step. The written submission can often involve submitting a 10-15 page response, plus exhibits. It is not unusual for a submission to be 30-60 pages when exhibits are included. As a result it is important to consult with an attorney that is familiar with the NSA security clearance process.
3. First Level Personal Appearance
Once the individual’s response to the SOR is received by the NSA within the deadline, they will be contacted to schedule the Personal Appearance, if that option has been requested. The individual and their attorney will then travel to the NSA for the Personal Appearance. You should build in time to get through security in order to make your appointment on time. In the future, it is likely that this may be transitioned into a virtual (remote) appearance. During the Personal Appearance, the individual and their attorney will sit across from the adjudicator and an NSA attorney. They will very well have a large binder in front of them with information about your case that you have not yet seen.
The security official will then start the Personal Appearance. Typically, at this point, the individual’s lawyer begins the discussion about the security concerns. In most cases, lawyers ask the individual questions about the case in order to present evidence to the security personnel present. The meeting has a fixed time of 30 minutes. Usually, you will be notified when you have 5 minutes of presentation time left.
It is important to be prepared for the Personal Appearance given the amount of time that is allotted. Usually, when the presentation is finished, the security official present will ask some clarifying questions. It is common to expect 5-15 questions about your case depending on the issues raised. by the security official in the Personal Appearance. Once finished, the security official will let you know that they will submit their notes to the adjudicator and a decision at the first step will then be rendered when that occurs.
4. First Level Decision
Once the adjudicator reviews the security officials notes, the written response and their own internal file, a decision will be rendered. The decisions include permitting an individual to continue in the security process, reversing the denial, and a first-level denial. If the decision is favorable there is nothing further to be done and the matter should be resolved. If a negative decision is made, the individual will receive a new notice with the option to elect an appeal with the NSA Access Appeals Panel (AAP). Then the individual will have additional time to file an appeal. However, in this case, you will not meet directly with the NSA AAP, but rather submit a written appeal for their review and final vote. At this point a decision is rendered and is final.
5. Other Considerations for Appealing NSA Decisions
If an adverse clearance decision is rendered by the NSA, it is important to plan for the reapplication process with the NSA. It is also important to determine any impact that a final NSA clearance denial might have on other security clearances held by the contractor. Separate security clearances may require representation before other agencies. It is often important to challenge the security concerns with the NSA as if your security clearance is denied, any other agencies that you hold security clearances with will have your side of the story before they review the security concerns separately. NSA often notifies other federal agencies about their security clearance decisions.
For example, a negative NSA decision could affect an individual with a Department of War/Defense security clearance. In those types of circumstances, it is critical to respond to the NSA SOR. The response will remain in NSA security files and will be potentially available to other federal agencies in other security clearance evaluations. Other agencies will review their decision, your response and then decide whether to follow (or not follow) the NSA security clearance decision.
Common Reasons NSA Clearances Are Denied or Revoked
Security clearance decisions are based on trustworthiness and reliability factors. Common issues include:
Financial problems or unexplained debts
Criminal history or misconduct
Foreign influence or preference
Personal conduct concerns
Failure to disclose relevant information on clearance forms
- Polygraph-related issues
Identifying the root cause of your clearance denial is the first step in building an effective appeal strategy.
How a NSA Security Clearance Lawyer Helps
Security clearance appeals are not ordinary legal cases — they involve:
Complex federal regulations
Tight deadlines
Technical adjudication guidelines
An experienced lawyer can help you with:
✅ Reviewing your investigatory file and allegations
✅ Developing a persuasive written response
✅ Preparing you for your Security or AAP hearing
✅ Gathering and organizing strong mitigating evidence
✅ Communicating with NSA adjudicators on your behalf
Legal counsel at this stage significantly increases your chance of retaining or regaining clearance.
Frequently Asked Questions About NSA Security Clearance Appeals
Can you appeal an NSA security clearance denial?
Yes. Contractors and employees may appeal NSA security clearance denials or revocations through a written response and, in many cases, a hearing before a security officer or NSA Access Appeals Panel on appeal.
How long do I have to appeal an NSA clearance decision?
Deadlines are short. Security clearance applicants and holders have typically 10 days to respond to an initial decision requesting their options, which include (1) not responding (not recommended); (2) responding with a written response; and (3) responding with a written response and a Personal Appearance (usually recommended).
Do I need a lawyer to appeal an NSA security clearance?
While not required, legal representation significantly improves outcomes. NSA appeals involve classified procedures, strict deadlines, and detailed evidentiary standards.
What issues commonly cause NSA clearance denials?
Financial issues, foreign contacts, criminal conduct, personal conduct concerns, and omissions on security forms are common reasons.
Speak With an NSA Security Clearance Appeal Attorney Today
Whether you are a contractor, federal employee, cleared professional, or pending applicant, our security clearance lawyers understand the NSA’s unique process and appeal requirements. We offer personalized legal representation to help you navigate and win your appeal.
📞 Call (703) 668-0070
📍 Berry & Berry, PLLC – Serving clients nationwide
📩 Contact us for a confidential consultation
Federal employees, and former federal employees, often need access to personal records maintained by government agencies. These records may include an Official Personnel Folder (OPF), security clearance files, or documents related to administrative investigations.
At our firm, we are frequently retained to assist clients in obtaining these records. This article provides a general overview of the Privacy Act and how it applies to federal employees. Because every situation is unique, individuals should consult an attorney experienced in Privacy Act matters before submitting a request.

What Is the Privacy Act?
The Privacy Act of 1974, codified at 5 U.S.C. § 552a, governs how federal agencies collect, maintain, use, and disclose personal information. In general, the law prohibits agencies from releasing records about an individual without their consent, unless a specific exception applies.
One key exception allows individuals to request access to their own records:
- 5 U.S.C. § 552a(d)(1) grants individuals the right to review and obtain copies of records maintained about them.
The Privacy Act is often compared to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), but they serve different purposes:
- Privacy Act → Access to your own personal records
- FOIA → Access to government records not specific to you
In some cases, submitting a request under both the Privacy Act and FOIA can be beneficial, depending on the type of records sought.
Key Differences Between the Privacy Act and FOIA
Understanding the distinction between these two laws is important:
- Agencies often do not charge search fees under the Privacy Act
- Agencies may charge copying fees
- FOIA requests may involve broader access but can include search and processing fees
Because of these differences, strategic use of both statutes can improve results.
What Records Can Federal Employees Request?
The Privacy Act allows individuals to request existing records about themselves. However, agencies are not required to create new documents in response to a request.
Common examples of requested records include:
- Background investigation reports
- Security clearance files
- Security clearance database records (DISS and Scattered Castles)
- Administrative or internal investigation records
- Official Personnel Folder (OPF)
- Disciplinary action records
There are many additional types of records that may be available depending on the agency and circumstances.
How to Submit a Privacy Act Request
Privacy Act request requirements vary by agency, but most requests must include the following information:
- Full legal name
- Date and place of birth
- Social Security Number (often required for identification)
- Current mailing or email address
- Signature
- A detailed description of the records requested (specificity is critical)
- A sworn declaration or notarized statement
- Copies of identification documents
Because requirements frequently change and errors can delay processing, working with experienced legal counsel is strongly recommended, especially for complex or sensitive matters.
Why Legal Guidance Matters
Privacy Act requests can become complicated when dealing with:
- Security clearance issues
- Adverse personnel actions
- Investigations or disciplinary records
- Missing or incomplete files
An attorney familiar with federal employment law and Privacy Act procedures can help ensure:
- Proper formatting and submission
- Strategic use of FOIA alongside the Privacy Act
- Faster and more complete responses
- Protection of your legal interests
Contact Us
If you need assistance preparing a Privacy Act request or obtaining federal employment records, our office can help.
Call: (703) 668-0070
Website: www.berrylegal.com
Schedule a consultation today to discuss your situation with an experienced attorney.

When a Department of Justice (DOJ) component such as the FBI denies or revokes an individual’s eligibility for access to classified information, the process does not end there. In many cases, the applicant or employee has the right to seek reconsideration and, if that effort is unsuccessful, to appeal to the Department of Justice Access Review Committee, commonly called the “ARC.” Under DOJ regulations (28 CFR § 17.15), the ARC reviews appeals from denials or revocations of eligibility for access to classified information, and its decision is generally final unless the Attorney General elects to personally exercise appeal authority.
Understanding the DOJ Access Review Committee (ARC) Appeal Process
This article discusses the DOJ security clearance appeal process. The ARC process is highly important, but it is also very procedural. Understanding the timing, submission requirements, and hearing format can make a meaningful difference in how an appeal is presented and the possibility for success.
Before the ARC – First Level of Review
Before a matter reaches the ARC, the DOJ component involved will first issue a decision denying an individual’s request for a security clearance. Upon issuing this initial denial, the individual will be provided with an opportunity to request the records relied upon and submit a written request for reconsideration. You must request the records within 30 days of receipt of the denial notice. Your written request for reconsideration is due within 30 days of your receipt of the documents relied upon, or the denial letter, whichever is later.
Following the submission of the request for reconsideration, which should be provided with explanation and evidence outlining why the individual does not pose a current security risk, the component will make a first-level decision. If the component upholds the denial or revocation in the first-level decision, the individual may then elect to appeal the matter further to the ARC.
Requesting an Appeal to the ARC
A DOJ clearance applicant or employee generally has 30 days from receipt of the first-level decision to file a written appeal to the ARC under the governing regulation. Because that deadline arrives quickly, it is wise to begin preparing the appeal as soon as the first-level denial is issued. Waiting too long can compress the time available to gather supporting records, prepare a written submission, and decide whether to request a personal appearance before the ARC.
What Must Be Included in the ARC Appeal
In our experience, the ARC appeal submission should include the following four items:
- The applicant’s full name, address, and telephone number;
- The name, address, and telephone number of the attorney or representative, if there is one;
- Any written statement, relevant documents, materials, or other information the applicant wants the ARC to consider; and
- A statement indicating whether the applicant does or does not wish to appear personally before the ARC.
Choosing a Written Appeal or ARC Hearing
A person appealing to the ARC may proceed on the written record alone or may request to appear personally before the Committee. In our practice, we generally recommend requesting a personal appearance.
That recommendation is grounded in the realities of these proceedings. A live appearance gives the applicant and counsel a fuller opportunity to explain the background of the case, address perceived security concerns directly, respond to the component’s position, and answer questions from ARC members in real time. A written submission is important in every case, but a personal appearance often allows for a more comprehensive presentation.
ARC Hearing Scheduling
After the appeal is submitted, applicants who request a personal appearance will eventually be contacted to schedule that appearance. One important practical point is that scheduling can happen faster than many people expect. In a recent matter handled by our office, the scheduling notice provided a hearing date only about three weeks later.
That means preparation should begin before the formal notice arrives. Supporting records, mitigation evidence, chronology, and hearing themes should be assembled early so there is no scramble once a date is set.
Virtual and In-Person Appearance Options
The ARC appearance may be conducted virtually or in person. When held in person, the proceeding takes place at the DOJ’s headquarters in Washington, D.C.
Employees or applicants should think strategically about which format best serves the case. Virtual appearances may be more convenient and cost-effective. In-person appearances may, in some matters, provide a stronger setting for presentation and advocacy. The right choice depends on the facts, the individual, and the overall theory of the appeal.
Additional Submissions Before the Hearing
If additional materials need to be submitted after the appeal is filed, they can usually still be provided in advance of the hearing. In our experience, any such additional documents or information should be submitted at least 15 days before the hearing date.
This is another reason to avoid waiting until the last minute. Mitigation evidence often takes time to gather. Medical records, counseling records, financial documentation, character letters, employment materials, and explanatory affidavits can all take longer to obtain than expected. Additional materials involving the Whole-Person Concept can be submitted as well.
If the scheduled hearing date presents a genuine conflict, an extension may be requested. That request should be made promptly and with a clear explanation.
What Happens at the ARC Proceeding
Individuals are often anxious because they do not know what the hearing will look like. Although every case is different, the ARC proceeding is generally orderly and professional.
On the day of the hearing, the applicant attends with counsel if represented. There are typically approximately three DOJ officials present as members of the ARC. The ARC is comprised of the Deputy Attorney General or a designee, the Assistant Attorney General for National Security or a designee, and the Assistant Attorney General for Administration or a designee.
The DOJ component involved in the case, such as the FBI, also appears through a representative to present their position. DOJ regulations specifically provide that the Department Security Officer has an opportunity to present relevant information in writing, or in person if the applicant appears personally before the ARC.
In our experience, the hearing generally unfolds as follows:
The Chair opens the proceeding, makes introductions, and gives a brief overview of the matter. The ARC then turns to the applicant and/or the applicant’s attorney for opening remarks. Approximately 30 minutes is typically allotted for that presentation. After the applicant’s side concludes, the agency component is usually given about 30 minutes to present its remarks. Once both sides have been heard, ARC members ask questions of both the applicant and the agency representative. After the questioning concludes, the proceeding ends. The meeting is recorded.
ARC members are generally well prepared. They have usually reviewed the file and supporting materials in advance and tend to ask thoughtful, focused questions to both sides.
The Legal Standard Remains Demanding
Even with a strong presentation, applicants should understand that this is not an ordinary administrative appeal. DOJ regulations make clear that an ARC determination on eligibility for access to classified information is a discretionary security decision, that access is granted only when the facts show that access is clearly consistent with the national security interest of the United States, and that any doubt is resolved in favor of national security. That standard is demanding. Successful appeals require more than disagreement with the initial decision. They require a careful showing that the concerns identified by the component are either unsupported, outdated, mitigated, or outweighed by the full record.
When to Expect a Final Decision
The ARC will issue its final written decision as “expeditiously as possible.” The timeline is not set, but a good expectation is around 60 days (always subject to change).
Although every case is fact-specific, individuals should use the post-hearing period to remain available in case counsel needs to address any administrative follow-up. Once issued, the ARC’s decision is generally the Department’s final decision in the matter. Another good resource in reviewing ARC appeals was published by the DOJ, here.
Contact Us
The DOJ ARC process is one of the most important stages in a security-clearance matter involving the DOJ security clearance appeals process. It is formal, deadline-driven, and substantively significant. The written appeal must be prepared carefully, and when a personal appearance is requested, hearing preparation should begin early. At Berry & Berry, PLLC, we guide clients from the initial written response to hearing preparation and ARC presentation. A well-prepared appeal can ensure that the ARC receives the fullest possible picture of the individual, the underlying concerns, and the reasons continued eligibility for access should be granted. If you need assistance with a security clearance issue, please contact our office at 703-668-0070 or at www.berrylegal.com to schedule a consultation.
For many federal employees a security clearance is a requirement of employment. When a clearance is denied or revoked after the appeals process is exhausted, the federal agency will often move forward with a proposal to remove the employee from their position unless a suitable reassignment is available.

Because of this risk, it is extremely important for federal employees to actively protect and defend their security clearance at the earliest stage of a security investigation or denial.
At Berry & Berry, PLLC, our attorneys regularly represent federal employees nationwide in security clearance matters and federal employment disputes. Learn more about our federal employment practice.
What Happens When a Federal Employee Loses a Security Clearance?
Many federal positions, particularly in defense, intelligence, and law enforcement require an active security clearance as a condition of employment. If an employee ultimately loses that clearance, the agency must determine whether:
The employee can be reassigned to another position that does not require a clearance, or
The agency may remove the employee from federal service.
In many cases, reassignment options are limited or unavailable, which means that removal from federal employment becomes the likely outcome.
This reality highlights why it is essential for federal employees to seek legal advice early in the security clearance process before a security clearance is lost.
Our firm represents federal employees in matters involving security clearance investigations, denials, revocations, and appeals. Learn more about security clearance representation.
MSPB Appeals After a Security Clearance-Based Removal
Federal employees who are removed from their positions due to the loss of a security clearance often ask whether they can appeal the decision to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB).
However, MSPB review in these types of cases is extremely limited.
The Supreme Court held in Department of the Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518 (1988) that the MSPB generally does not have the authority to review the underlying merits of a security clearance determination. The Federal Circuit later reaffirmed this principle in Cheney v. Department of Justice, 479 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2007).
In other words, the MSPB typically cannot second-guess a federal agency’s decision to deny or revoke a security clearance.
Limited Issues the MSPB May Review
Although the MSPB cannot review the security clearance determination itself, the Board may consider certain procedural issues related to the employment action.
For example, the MSPB may evaluate:
- Harmful procedural error that could have changed the outcome of a case (i.e. not following Agency policy).
Whether the agency had a formal policy requiring reassignment of employees who lose their clearance.
Whether a suitable reassignment position existed at the time of the removal.
Why Early Legal Representation Matters
Because the ability to challenge a removal based on a security clearance denial is limited, it is critical for federal employees to respond proactively to security clearance concerns.
Early legal guidance may help:
Address issues raised during the background investigation
Respond to a Statement of Reasons (SOR)
Prepare for security clearance hearings or appeals
Develop mitigation strategies under the Adjudicative Guidelines
Our attorneys at Berry & Berry, PLLC focus on representing federal employees in security clearance and federal employment law matters nationwide.
Contact a Federal Employment and Security Clearance Lawyer
If you are facing a security clearance denial, revocation, or federal employment action, it is important to seek legal guidance as early as possible.
Each security clearance case and federal employment matter involves unique facts, procedures, and deadlines.
Berry & Berry, PLLC represents federal employees, contractors, and military personnel in security clearance and federal employment matters throughout the United States.
📞 Phone: (703) 668-0070
🌐 Website: https://www.berrylegal.com
📩 Or visit our Contact Page to request a consultation:
Contact Berry & Berry, PLLC
Our security clearance lawyers represent individuals with Special Access Program (SAP) issues and concerns. SAP access can be important for traditional federal agencies like the Department of Defense or for the Intelligence Community.
SAP access can be sought for both federal employees and government contractors.

Many clearance holders assume that once they have obtained a Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmented Information (TS/SCI) clearance, the hardest part of the clearance process is behind them. In reality, for some professionals, the next step, being considered for SAP access, introduces a new and often misunderstood set of requirements. The upgrade process is different than for those seeking to upgrade from a Secret clearance to a Top Secret clearance or other more traditional security clearance upgrades.
After many years of representing and defending security clearance holders and applicants, I have seen experienced professionals surprised by the additional scrutiny that accompanies seeking SAP access. Understanding how SAP differs from TS/SCI access can help clearance holders prepare for the process and avoid unnecessary delays or adverse outcomes.
What is a SAP?
A SAP is a program established for a specific class of classified information that requires safeguarding and access requirements that exceed those normally required for security clearance access. A SAP can be acknowledged or not acknowledged. The existence of higher-level SAP programs in certain federal agencies might not even be acknowledged.
A common misconception is that SAP access is simply a different type of security clearance (e.g. TS/SCI). In fact, TS/SCI is a security clearance eligibility determination, while SAP access is program-specific authorization layered on top of an existing clearance.
To be eligible for SAP access, an individual must already hold the appropriate clearance level, usually Top Secret, and have a demonstrated need to know. However, meeting those baseline requirements does not guarantee SAP approval. Each SAP has its own access criteria, security procedures, and approval authorities. It seems like no two agencies are the same.
Additional Scrutiny Involved for SAP Access
SAP access often involves enhanced vetting beyond the underlying TS/SCI investigation. This may include additional reviews of prior clearance history, candor, employment conduct, financial issues, foreign contacts, and prior reporting compliance.
Issues that were previously mitigated or resolved at the TS/SCI level may be reexamined in the SAP context. Think of it as additional scrutiny over the same issues. SAP authorities tend to apply a more risk-averse standard, particularly when programs involve especially sensitive technologies, operations, or intelligence sources.
A SAP Hypothetical
Consider a clearance holder who has maintained a TS/SCI clearance for several years without incident. During a prior reinvestigation, the individual disclosed a foreign national mother living overseas. The relationship was reviewed, mitigated, and ultimately deemed acceptable for TS/SCI eligibility.
When that same individual is later nominated for SAP access, the foreign family connection is reevaluated. Although nothing about the relationship has changed, the SAP authority determines that the potential risk, however remote, is incompatible with the program’s sensitivity. The individual retains their TS/SCI clearance but is denied SAP access and cannot fill the position.
This type of outcome is not uncommon and illustrates that SAP decisions often turn on program-specific risk tolerance rather than traditional clearance eligibility.
Foreign Influence Concerns, Contacts and Travel
For SAP access, foreign influence is a key concern. Foreign contacts and foreign travel frequently take on greater significance during the SAP approval process. Relationships or travel that were fully disclosed and adjudicated during a TS/SCI investigation may still be scrutinized anew.
Contacts involving countries with adversarial relationships with the United States can be especially problematic for those seeking access. SAP authorities may impose additional reporting requirements, restrict travel, or deny access altogether based on assessments that differ from standard clearance adjudications.
For obvious reasons, those adjudicating SAP access are especially concerned with individuals that could be susceptible to coercion from hostile countries.
Prior Clearance History is Reviewed Again for SAP Access
For clearance holders upgrading to SAP access, past behavior often matters as much as current circumstances. Security offices and SAP authorities frequently review whether an individual has complied consistently with reporting obligations related to finances, foreign contacts, criminal conduct, outside activities, and personal conduct.
In my experience, SAP access denials often stem not from disqualifying conduct, but from perceived lapses in judgment or candor. Even minor reporting failures can be viewed as indicators of unreliability when evaluated under SAP standards.
Limited Due Process and Appeals
Another important difference between regular security clearance eligibility and SAP access is the level of discretion afforded to program authorities. Think discretion. SAP access decisions are highly discretionary and may offer limited avenues for appeal or review. Some agencies, like the U.S. Air Force / Space Force, offer some level of SAP Access review. Many SAP programs offer the ability to rebut issues raised in writing. It is important to have a security clearance lawyer for these types of responses.
Unlike traditional clearance adjudications, SAP access determinations may not provide detailed explanations for denials or revocations. In others, an individual may be provided the investigative file which provides reasons for the denial. Clearance holders should understand that even a perfect TS/SCI clearance record does not automatically mean that they will be approved for SAP Access.
Furthermore, if you are denied SAP access it will not necessarily adversely affect your existing security clearance. I have plenty of clients who have been denied for SAP Access that still retain their TS/SCI security clearance.
Contact Us for Legal Assistance in SAP Issues
Upgrading from a security clearance (Secret, TS/SCI) to SAP access is not a routine administrative step and may require the advice of counsel. SAP access in unique with heightened scrutiny, much greater agency discretion, and fewer due process protections. Clearance holders who understand these differences are better positioned to navigate the process successfully. If you need legal assistance regarding SAP issues or security clearance matters, please call our office at (703) 668-0070 or reach us here.
We represent federal employees in the Federal Employee EEO complaint process. The Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) complaint process for federal employees can be challenging, especially if you’re experiencing discrimination or harassment. It is important to understand your federal employee rights as you move forward with your complaint. While each case is different, here are 14 tips to consider during the federal employee EEO complaint process.

1. Understand Your Rights First
Before taking action, familiarize yourself with your rights under federal employee EEO laws and regulations. These laws prohibit discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, and genetic information. Many federal employees get bad advice on what constitutes an EEO complaint. Knowing your rights is crucial as it helps you recognize if you have a valid complaint or should take another approach.
2. Gather Documentation/ Possible Evidence
EEO cases are documentation-heavy. As a result, it is important to retain all documentation that is involved in your case. Such information can include emails, text messages, witness statements, policies, notes, photographs, video, and other documentation. For instance, if you were sexually harassed by a manager and you have emails demonstrating this, it would be important to have them when preparing to file a complaint.
3. Be Timely
It is critical to be timely when filing an EEO complaint. Typically, there is only a 45-day time period in which to initiate a complaint. There are some exceptions involving hostile work environment claims. However, it is critical to plan to file your claim on time. If not, the best claim in the world may be dismissed. Each federal agency has its own procedures to follow, so make sure to consult your agency’s EEO office for specific guidance.
4. Spell Out Your Claims Clearly in the Informal Complaint
When initiating the informal EEO complaint within 45 days, put it in writing. Additionally, you should be clear about all of the issues you are raising. We find that initiating the informal complaint verbally, with no written record, can often lead to a disagreement about what was disclosed within the 45-day period. In many cases, we treat the informal complaint with as much detail as would be provided in the formal complaint. It is important to describe the incidents of discrimination in detail, including dates, locations, and the individuals involved. Clarity can prevent misunderstandings and help the EEO counselor address your complaint more effectively.
5. Think About Solutions Before Filing
Before initiating the informal complaint, consider what you may want to resolve the case. In many instances, if there is a plan to resolve the complaint in advance, an attempt to mediate the dispute can take place. Given the longer nature of the EEO complaint process, settling early, where possible, may be the best option. If the parties agree to alternative dispute resolution (ADR), they have a chance to resolve it. If successful, both parties will resolve the complaint in a settlement agreement.
6. Know the Timelines and Process
The EEO complaint process has specific timelines. If the complaint is not resolved, a number of timelines will start. A federal employee will receive their notice of right to file a formal EEO complaint. This usually has a deadline of 15 days. Additionally, after you file your complaint, the agency typically has a set period of time to investigate your claims (180 days).
7. Respond to Agency Dismissal Attempts
In some cases, federal agencies will attempt to dismiss (and not investigate) your EEO complaint. It is advisable to respond to these attempts and explain why the complaint should not be dismissed. Even if dismissed, these claims can later be potentially revived before an administrative judge if you file a response describing why the agency has to investigate your claims.
8. Follow-up If Investigation Delayed
After filing the EEO complaint, there is often a delay in starting the investigation. In some cases, the agency forgets or is slow in appointing an investigator. In such cases, it is important to follow up with the agency’s EEO office to see if an investigator has been appointed and obtain their contact information. In most cases, the EEO investigator appointed is from a third-party contractor. The sooner that you obtain the EEO investigator’s contact information, the better.
9. Provide Names of Witnesses and Documents to the Investigator
Agencies are required to conduct an impartial and fair investigation. That said, federal employees can’t assume that EEO investigators will know who to question or what documents to seek. Investigators usually have some idea where to start. Usually, it is important to provide a list of witnesses and documents that the EEO investigator can use to start the investigation. It is often the case that EEO investigators will miss key witnesses unless they are identified. You can help yourself by providing this information to the EEO Investigator.
10. Cooperate with the Investigator
It is important to cooperate with the assigned investigator. It is often the case that EEO investigators will ask for additional documents, rebuttals to witness statements or other responses by certain deadlines. If a complainant doesn’t comply with these requests, it can hurt the investigation and the case. Even though the EEO complaint process can sometimes be difficult, it is important to stay professional and cooperative throughout the process.
11. File Amended Claims if New Issues Arise
If, during the course of the EEO investigation, new EEO issues arise, you can often file an amendment to your EEO complaint. Doing so can reset the timelines, but it may be important to consolidate new EEO complaint issues that come up during the course of the investigation. For example, a federal employee files an EEO complaint against a supervisor, and the supervisor later tries to discipline the employee. It would be likely be important to amend the original claims and include a new count of retaliation.
12. Keep an Eye on the Investigation Timeline
An EEO investigation is generally required to be completed in 180 days. After this period of time, a complainant can move their case to the hearing process if the investigation is not completed. However, in some cases, it is important to let the EEO investigator complete their investigation first. If the wait is minimal, then it is better to have the Report of Investigation to start your case than not.
13. Keep Records of Correspondence with Agency and EEO Investigator
It is important to keep records of all contact with the agency’s EEO office and the EEO investigator. There could be a dispute later about what issues were raised or whether or not you asked a certain witness to be interviewed. The best defense to these issues is to keep a copy of all emails and correspondence sent to the agency.
14. Hire a Federal EEO Lawyer
The EEO complaint process can be complex with many twists and turns. It is important to retain an experienced lawyer in federal EEO complaints to help you from the start. The best time to hire a lawyer is before the 45-day timeline for initiating EEO contact starts.
Contact Us for Federal EEO Complaint Representation
Filing an EEO complaint can be a challenging process, but knowing your rights and following the proper steps can put you in the best position moving forward. By gathering evidence, being clear about the allegations in your complaint, and hiring experienced EEO counsel, you can navigate the process with greater confidence. If you are in need of experienced federal employee EEO lawyers please contact us at (703) 668-0070 or through our website to schedule a consultation.
Quick Definition:
An indefinite suspension places a federal employee in a non-duty, non-pay status without a set end date, typically pending an investigation, medical determination, or security clearance action.
Indefinite suspensions are a unique and serious issue in federal employment law, particularly for positions requiring a security clearance. As a nationwide federal employment attorney, We regularly advise federal employees across the United States who have been proposed for an indefinite suspension due to clearance, criminal or medical-related issues.

These types of cases can place employees in professional and financial limbo for extended periods, often with limited due-process protections and unclear timelines for resolution. Legal counsel is important.
What Is an Indefinite Suspension in Federal Employment?
An indefinite suspension is considered a non-disciplinary adverse action used by federal agencies when an employee is deemed unable to perform the essential functions of their position.
Federal agencies may impose an indefinite suspension for one of three reasons and the suspension remains in place until the issue is resolved, with no defined end date.
From a federal employment attorney’s perspective, these actions are among the most disruptive and legally complex employment measures agencies can take.
When Agencies Use Indefinite Suspensions
Federal agencies generally use indefinite suspension in three major scenarios:
1. Criminal Investigations or Charges
If an agency has reasonable cause to believe an employee committed a crime that could lead to imprisonment, it may place the employee on indefinite suspension while the criminal matter is pending.
2. Medical or Fitness-for-Duty Concerns
An agency may suspend an employee if continued presence in the workplace could pose a danger due to medical issues — pending a fitness-for-duty determination.
3. Security Clearance Suspensions
If an employee’s access to classified information — essential to their job — is suspended or revoked, the agency may impose an indefinite suspension pending the clearance decision.
These situations must be supported by legitimate agency reasons and tied to the efficiency of the service, a legal standard in federal adverse actions.
Why Indefinite Suspensions Are Common in Federal Employment
Unlike private-sector employment, many federal positions require ongoing eligibility for access to classified or sensitive information. As a result, federal employees are uniquely vulnerable to indefinite suspensions tied to:
Pending security clearance investigations
Clearance suspensions or proposed revocations
Adjudication delays
Allegations that remain unresolved
Even when allegations are disputed or unproven, agencies often proceed with suspension based solely on clearance uncertainty.
Types of Indefinite Suspensions
Federal employees may be placed on:
✔ Indefinite Suspension With Pay
Often used when the agency temporarily removes an employee from duty but continues pay status, usually via a short memorandum.
✔ Indefinite Suspension Without Pay
More serious — requires formal notice and due process. It removes the employee from both duty and pay status until the triggering conditions are resolved.
Most concerns arise when the suspension is without pay, due to the financial impact on a federal employee.
How Indefinite Suspensions Differ From Other Federal Adverse Actions
Indefinite suspensions differ significantly from removals or fixed-term suspensions:
No predetermined end date
Often framed as non-disciplinary
Frequently involve national security authority
May limit MSPB appeal rights
Because clearance, criminal and medical issues frequently take months or years, indefinite suspensions can quietly become long-term employment separations.
Due Process and Legal Rights Under Federal Employment Law
Indefinite suspensions raise serious due-process concerns. While federal employees are entitled to procedural protections under civil service laws, agencies often argue that those protections are reduced when national security or clearance authority is invoked.
As nationwide federal employment attorneys, we routinely see agencies assert broad discretion even when:
The underlying allegations are contested
No final clearance decisions or criminal charges have been issued
Employees are denied access to critical evidence
This makes early legal strategy essential.
Appealing an Indefinite Suspension
Federal employees may appeal an indefinite suspension to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB). When doing so, they should understand:
The agency must demonstrate that it had reasonable cause for the suspension.
The suspension must promote the efficiency of the service and have an ascertainable condition that will end it.
If procedural due process was denied — for example, insufficient notice or an unclear basis — the MSPB may reverse or remand the action.
Additional guidance is available through the MSPB appeals process for federal employees.
The Real-World Impact on Federal Employees
Federal employees placed on indefinite suspension often experience:
Extended loss of income
Career stagnation or derailment
Clearance damage affecting future employment
Significant emotional and financial stress
Many employees assume the suspension will be short. In reality, clearance delays are common, and prolonged suspensions are the norm.
Why Federal Employees Nationwide Seek Legal Counsel Early
Federal employment law—and especially security clearance law—is highly specialized. Employees facing indefinite suspension benefit from early legal representation to:
Protect procedural rights
Shape the agency record
Respond strategically to proposed actions
Minimize long-term clearance damage
Waiting to seek counsel can significantly limit available options.
Frequently Asked Questions About Indefinite Suspensions
Is an indefinite suspension disciplinary?
No. Agencies typically characterize indefinite suspensions as non-disciplinary. However, the impact can be as severe as a removal.
Can an indefinite suspension last indefinitely?
Yes. There is no fixed time limit, and suspensions may last as long as the issue (clearance, criminal, medical) remains unresolved.
Can a federal employee be placed on indefinite suspension without pay?
Yes. An agency may impose an indefinite suspension without pay, but only after providing required due process, including advance notice, the opportunity to review evidence, and a chance to respond. These suspensions are considered adverse actions under federal regulations.
Will an indefinite suspension affect future federal employment?
It can. How the matter is handled may affect future clearance eligibility and federal job opportunities.
Protecting Your Federal Career
Indefinite suspensions sit at the heart of federal employment law. Federal employees across the country should not assume these matters will resolve quickly or without lasting consequences. For a more technical overview, see our resource page on indefinite suspension for federal employees.
Summary
Indefinite suspension for federal employees is a powerful administrative tool used in serious employment situations. They:
Occur without a fixed end date and typically involve major adverse scenarios
Must meet due process requirements under federal regulations
Can be appealed through the MSPB with proper legal strategy
If you or a colleague are facing an indefinite suspension, it’s important to act quickly to protect your rights and career.
📞 Call (703) 668-0070 for a confidential consultation or click here.


