Foreign Influence Issues and Security Clearances

Our DC-Metropolitan Based Law Firm Specializes in Employment, Security Clearance, and Retirement Law.

Our law firm represents federal employees, military personnel and government contractors in security clearance issues involving foreign influence and preference.  Foreign influence concerns have always been a major security concern because there are potential risks when a clearance holder or applicant’s family or close friends are subject to potential duress or influence by a foreign power. There are also major concerns when an individual owns too much property or other assets in a foreign country with adverse interests towards the United States.

As a result, foreign Influence issues have long been major considerations in determining whether to grant or renew a security clearance.

What are Foreign Influence Concerns?

security concerns foreign influenceSecurity concerns involving foreign influence are evaluated by federal agencies under Guideline B of the Adjudicative Guidelines in Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4).  The security concerns involving SEAD 4 are listed as follows:

The Concern: Foreign contacts and interests, including, but not limited to, business, financial, and property interests, are a national security concern if they result in divided alliance They may also be a national security concern if they create circumstances in which the individual may be manipulated or induced to help a foreign person, group, organization, or government in a way inconsistent with U.S. interests or otherwise made vulnerable to pressure or coercion by any foreign interest.  Assessment of foreign contacts and interests should consider the country in which the foreign contact or interest is located, including, but not limited to, considerations such as whether it is known to target U.S. citizens to obtain classified or sensitive information or is associated with a risk of terrorism.

The specific conditions that may raise security concerns include the following 9 security issues listed in Paragraph 7 of SEAD 4:

a. contact, regardless of method, with a foreign family member, business or professional associate, friend, or other person who is a citizen of or a resident in a foreign country if that contact creates a heightened risk of foreign exploitation, inducement, manipulation, pressure, or coercion;

b. connections to a foreign person, group, government, or country that create a potential conflict of interest between the individual’s obligation to protect classified or sensitive information or technology and the individual’ s desire to help a foreign person, group, or country by providing that information or technology;

c. failure to report or fully disclose, when required, association with a foreign person, group, government, or country;

d. counterintelligence information, whether classified or unclassified, that indicates the individual’s access to classified information or eligibility for a sensitive position may involve unacceptable risk to national security;

e. shared living quarters with a person or persons, regardless of citizenship status, if that relationship creates a heightened risk of foreign inducement, manipulation, pressure, or coercion;

f. substantial business, financial, or property interests in a foreign country, or in any foreign­ owned or foreign-operated business that could subject the individual to a heightened risk of foreign influence or exploitation or personal conflict of interest;

g. unauthorized association with a suspected or known agent, associate, or employee of a foreign intelligence entity;

h. indications that representatives or nationals from a foreign country are acting to increase the vulnerability of the individual to possible future exploitation, inducement, manipulation, pressure, or coercion; and

i. conduct, especially while traveling or residing outside the U.S., that may make the individual vulnerable to exploitation, pressure, or coercion by a foreign person, group, government, or country.

Potential Mitigation of Security Concerns Under Guideline B

In terms of potential mitigation regarding these potential security concerns, the following mitigating considerations are potentially available under Paragraph 8 of SEAD 4:

a. the nature of the relationships with foreign persons, the country in which these persons are located, or the positions or activities of those persons in that country are such that it is unlikely the individual will be placed in a position of having to choose between the interests of a foreign individual, group, organization, or government and the interests of the United States;

b. there is no conflict of interest, either because the individual’s sense of loyalty or obligation to the foreign person, or allegiance to the group, government, or country is so minimal, or the individual has such deep and longstanding relationships and loyalties in the United States, that the individual can be expected to resolve any conflict of interest in favor of the U.S. interest;

c. contact or communication with foreign citizens is so casual and infrequent that there is little likelihood that it could create a risk for foreign influence or exploitation;

d. the foreign contacts and activities are on U.S. Government business or are approved by the agency head or designee;

e. the individual has promptly complied with existing agency requirements regarding the reporting of contacts, requests, or threats from persons, groups, or organizations from a foreign country; and

f. the value or routine nature of the foreign business, financial, or property interests is such that they are unlikely to result in a conflict and could not be used effectively to influence, manipulate, or pressure the individual.

Potential Foreign Influence Concerns for Clearance Holders

Here are just a few examples of security clearance issues that can arise from foreign ties for security clearance holders and applicants:

  1. An individual’s uncle is a general in the Indian Armed Forces;
  2. An individual inherits a house from their mother in Pakistan;
  3. An individual marries a woman who has assets in Taiwan;
  4. An individual previously served in another country’s military;
  5. An individual’s mother currently lives in China;
  6. An individual is close friends with an foreign service employee of another country;
  7. An individual’s father is a citizen and resident of China and receives a pension;
  8. An individual’s entire family lives in China and he/she has frequent contact with them;
  9. An individual’s mother resides in Bulgaria;
  10. An individual maintains investments in foreign countries;
  11. An individual’s property an assets in another country outweigh their assets in the United States.

The number of examples is countless, and these are just a few of the types of cases we see on a regular basis.

Different Strategies for Handling Foreign Influence Concerns in Clearance Cases

There are multiple different types of situations that can raise foreign influence concerns for security clearance holders and applicants. When a security concern does arise, there are a number of strategies for attempting to mitigate cases involving potential security concerns.

The first issue that we usually evaluate is the foreign country involved. The United States treats foreign influence concerns vastly different depending on the country. For instance, a foreign relative in the United Kingdom or Germany would be evaluated completely different than an individual that has a foreign relative in China or Russia.

Next, it is important to first evaluate the closeness of any potential foreign relatives and friends in the context of whether or not they are truly close in nature or not. Where appropriate, it is important to argue that foreign relatives or friends are not close in nature or are not connected to a foreign government.  Closeness can be illustrated by a minimum of contact (email, telephone, in person visits) with individuals in foreign countries. Often, it is helpful to explain, in detail, how a foreign contact is not as close as they may appear on the application.

Also, in some cases it can be important to show how the clearance applicant or clearance holder has far more ties to the United States, in assets, family and friends and organizations than to a foreign country they are also tied to. For this type of situation, it is very important to obtain documentation to outweigh such ties, such as showing assets in the United States versus those in a foreign country. Other unique factors can come into play, such as if the individual in the United States is involved significantly in the community, earns a good salary and/or has children in the United States.

Early Mitigation in Foreign Influence Cases

When a clearance holder or applicant has ties to a foreign country, such as close family or assets, it is very important to evaluate these situations early, to attempt to mitigate security concerns. There are many methods available to attempt to mitigate foreign influence concerns, but it is important to focus on the following factors:

(1) Which country does the perceived foreign influence involve?;

(2) What is the  nature of the foreign property or asset; and

(3) Explain how these ties or assets are outweighed by assets, loyalty and family located in the United States.

There are many different mitigation strategies in foreign influence cases, but it is important to obtain advice from a security clearance lawyer when facing these issues.

Contact Us

When a clearance holder or applicant is facing foreign influence security clearance concerns it is important to obtain legal advice and/or legal representation. Our law firm advises individuals in the security clearance process. We can be contacted at www.berrylegal.com or by telephone at (703) 668-0070.

We defend federal and local (Virginia, DC, Maryland) law enforcement officers and supervisors in integrity issues. As you know, integrity is the cornerstone of law enforcement. The public’s trust, the judicial system’s reliability, and the pursuit of justice all depend on the credibility of those sworn to uphold the law. Yet, a single lie or even an omission—on a report, under oath, or in any official or unofficial capacity—can end a career, compromise a case, and permanently tarnish an officer’s reputation. This is especially true under the legal doctrine established in Giglio v. United States (1972), a landmark Supreme Court case that has lasting implications for law enforcement officers today. It leaves little room for even one mistake. When these types of issues arise, we defend law enforcement officers. 

What Is the Giglio Rule?

The Giglio decision mandates that the prosecution must disclose any information that could impeach the credibility of a government witness—including law enforcement officers. If an officer has a known history of dishonesty, bias, or other impeaching conduct, prosecutors are obligated to inform criminal defense attorneys. Failure to do so can violate a defendant’s right to due process and result in overturned convictions.

Put simply, Giglio means that an officer’s credibility isn’t just important—it’s critical. Many prosecutors, when faced with an officer with negative Giglio information to produce will simply drop an otherwise completely good case. 

When a Lie Becomes a Career-Ending Problem

Giglio law enforcementAn officer caught in a lie—whether it’s falsifying a report, shading the truth in testimony, or misleading internal affairs—may be placed on a “Brady list,” “Giglio list,” or “Lewis List” by prosecutors. These lists identify officers whose testimony may no longer be considered reliable. Being on such a list can make it nearly impossible to testify in court, which, in turn, can severely restrict an officer’s ability to perform essential duties.

In many federal agencies and departments, officers who become Giglio-impaired are reassigned to non-enforcement roles or face proposed termination. When this happens, the prosecutor may inform the department or federal agency that they will decline to ever use you again as a witness. This frequently will cause a federal agency or department to place the officer on leave and initiate the termination process. A good example of how this can affect an officer came up in the case of Marin v. DHS (2025). In that case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit upheld a removal because a U.S. Attorney deemed the federal law enforcement officer to have credibility issues (i.e. Giglio).

And the stain of Giglio doesn’t just disappear—it can follow an officer throughout their career, even across state lines. When seeking a new law enforcement position, you almost always have to allow the new employer access to your old employer’s records.

Examples of Potential Giglio Violations in Action

  • An officer falsifies or omits a detail in a report to make probable cause appear stronger in a criminal case.
  • An officer is found to have lied during an internal affairs investigation.
  • An officer was found to have lied in his tax filings and the department or agency finds out.
  • An officer doesn’t lie but omits key details during an investigatory interview.
  • An officer withholds key facts during testimony, later discovered through body-worn camera footage.

Each of these actions, if exposed, can render that officer’s future testimony suspect—potentially undermining any case in which they are involved. When this happens, it is commonly the case that the officer will potentially face termination. In some cases, the officer will be fortunate to be assigned to duties which wouldn’t subject the officer to having to testify in court.

How Giglio Can Affect You and Others

The damage extends beyond individual consequences. A single Giglio violation can:

  • Cause other officers or supervisors to be forced to testify against you.
  • Lead to civil liability for the officer.
  • Cause overturned convictions.
  • Require closed investigations to be reopened.
  • Damage the public’s trust in an entire department.
  • Invite civil liability for the agency.
  • Harm prosecutorial partnerships and coordination with the federal or local prosecutor’s office.

Protecting Your Credibility: Best Practices

  1. Tell the Truth—Always: This may seem basic, but it cannot be overstated. Accuracy and honesty must guide all official conduct. Of course, if there are legal issues involved, it is important to obtain legal advice from an attorney. If there is a criminal issue involved, legal advice before participating in an interview is critical. In some cases, not testifying will be the best course of action.
  2. No Omissions: If there is a material fact that is important in a case, but you are not asked about it in an interview, it is often important to disclose it. Not doing so can lead to a large of lack of candor, which is different than a dishonesty charge.
  3. Document Everything/Save Data: Meticulous, truthful documentation helps prevent misunderstandings and protects against false accusations. When situations that are unusual arise, it is often important to keep a journal of the actions you took (or other steps) if you know that you will be interviewed later.
  4. Own Mistakes Early: If you make an error, report it promptly. Transparency can mitigate long-term damage. Inlack of candor cases, coming forward early can sometimes avoid disciplinary issues. 
  5. Understand Departmental and Legal Obligations: Stay educated on your agency’s policies, Brady/Giglio requirements, and ethical expectations. They basically boil down to two things: (1) tell the truth in all situations, and (2) if questioned about an incident, do not leave out important details.  
  6. Seek Legal Guidance When in Doubt: If you face a potential credibility issue, consult a law enforcement attorney before proceeding. Disclosures, when criminal issues are at stake, may change how you approach investigative interviews or disciplinary defense.
  7. Legal Defense: If accused of dishonesty or lack of candor, it is critical to hire a law enforcement attorney to help defend you. Our lawyers defend law enforcement officers and supervisors in trial (civil service) boards, before police departments, before federal law enforcement agencies, and in front of the Merit Systems Protection Board or in arbitration.

Contact Us

We defend federal law enforcement officers nationwide, in addition to officers in Virginia, DC, and Maryland. Giglio issues must be handled carefully. In a profession built on public trust, even a single lie can dismantle years of honorable service. We defend law enforcement officers who run into Giglio issues. We can be contacted at (703) 668-0070 for a consultation or through our website.

NRO security clearance processOur security clearance attorneys represent government contractors and federal employees in the security clearance process at the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO). Each federal agency is different in evaluating security clearance issues, and the NRO is no different.  The NRO introduces some unique concepts in their security clearance appeals process.

The NRO security clearance appeals process is initially governed by Executive Order 12698, which delegates clearance processing to individual federal agencies. Furthermore, as the NRO is part of the Intelligence Community (IC), it has other regulations to follow by the DNI. Lastly, the NRO has its own rules for handling security clearance appeals. 

A. The NRO Clearance Process for Government Contractors

The security clearance process for government contractors at the NRO is a hybrid of the process used by the Department of Defense (DoD) but based on the same underlying clearance adjudication principles known as the adjudicative guidelines in SEAD 4. It is important to keep in mind that the NRO security clearance process is managed by their internal clearance appeals office. It is also important to understand that employees have the right to an attorney before the NRO during the stages of the security clearance appeals process. 

The following are the most common steps in the NRO contractor security clearance process. 

1.  Notification of Revocation or Denial of Security Clearance or Upgraded Access

When an NRO clearance holder or applicant has a security clearance issue with the NRO, they will receive a notice of revocation or denial letter, usually sent by the NRO security staff, listing the security concerns at issue and other rights. The security concerns will usually be set forth briefly in a 2-3 page letter. The letter will usually provide copies of the security guidelines at issue and a page entitled Information and Instructions for responding. The rights on review are set forth in some detail in the documents. The letter is similar to a Statement of Reasons (SOR) issued by other federal agencies.

There is a right to request a review of the decision. Additionally, there is a right to request the NRO Investigative File containing documents in the case. Individuals appealing the NRO decision will want to ensure that they make it known that they are seeking a Personal Appearance (PA) (a hearing) as well.  Currently, these rights must be exercised within 45 days to be timely.

2. Receipt of the Investigative File

If requested, you will receive the NRO Investigative File before you have to draft the written response. You will be provided with documentation (or at least a significant portion of it) relied upon by the NRO in denying the request for security access. Some parts of the file may be redacted, but one can usually discern the issues that need to be addressed. 

When the Investigative File is received, it is important to subsequently prepare and file a written response. In the response letter, if a PA has been requested, you will be reminded of two different options for a hearing: a PA or a Virtual Personal Appearance (VPA). The VPA follows a similar format, but travel for the hearing is not required.

3. Written Response to the NRO

Upon receipt of the Investigative File, the individual will generally want to provide a written response in preparation for the PA. It is usually important to provide these supporting documents in advance to give the adjudicator time to review them in advance of the PA. The documents usually need to be provided within a sufficient time prior to the scheduled PA. Most written responses tend to be 10-15 pages in length, plus exhibits. 

4. The Personal Appearance / Hearing

The next step in the NRO security clearance process is for the individual to present their response to the adjudicator during the PA or VPA. The lead adjudicator will be a senior government security officer. The NRO will notify you by letter about the PA hearing schedule. You should retain a security clearance lawyer to assist you with this presentation. These types of hearings typically take about an hour in length, but can last longer. The individual seeking to overturn the initial security clearance decision should be prepared to respond to the concerns at issue and also to potential questions by the adjudicator. The meeting will usually take place at the NRO Visitor’s Center or at another specified location. If the meeting is conducted virtually, the VPA will be heard by telephone.

5. Second Step Appeal Available

Following the PA or VPA, a written decision will be rendered. If the decision is unfavorable, the individual has the ability to appeal the decision to a second step appeal. The second step appeal is adjudicated by a panel of at least 3 senior security officers. This stage is in writing only and the appeal must be submitted within 30 days of the receipt of the denial. Their is no in person aspect to the second step appeal.

6. Final Clearance Decision and Next Steps

Once the second step review is completed, the panel will issue a final decision. If unfavorable, then the individual will not be able to apply for a security clearance through NRO for one year. Keep in mind that at any point in this process, the individual can withdraw their appeal before a decision is rendered. If the process has gone on for some time (1-2 years), it is not uncommon for an individual to file their response and even attend the PA or VPA and subsequently withdraw their appeal. The purpose behind doing so is to ensure that your side of the story is placed in the record and not have to wait for a final decision before reapplying.

B. The NRO Clearance Process for Federal Employees

The NRO security clearance process for federal employees is similar to that for government contractors. However, there are some differences. For instance, if an NRO federal employee has their security clearance revoked, it can lead to a removal from their federal employment before their appeal is complete. This is different from many other federal agencies. While the NRO will generally allow an individual to continue appealing their security clearance denial, even if removed, they may be without a position to return to if they are successful. In many ways, government contractors have more rights in this regard than NRO employees. Additionally, the security clearance process for NRO federal employees appears to run more quickly than that for government contractors, which takes longer.

Contact Us

When an individual is facing security clearance issues at the NRO or before another federal agency, it is important to obtain legal advice and potential legal representation.  Our law firm advises individuals in the security clearance process. We can be contacted here or by telephone at (703) 668-0070. 

Virginia workplace investigation

We represent employees in Virginia in employment investigations involving employee alleged misconduct. When you are notified that you may be the subject of a workplace investigation, it is important to seek legal advice and possible representation from a Virginia employment lawyer. It is always difficult for an employee to be notified that they are the subject of a workplace investigation, but we are here to help them defend their career if this occurs.

When a serious investigation is being conducted into your conduct, you need to be prepared to respond to any allegations through counsel. Do not leave your best interests in the hands of an employer and their investigator.

Employment Allegations Require Employer Investigations

It is common for employees to be investigated in the workplace. Virginia employers typically conduct workplace investigations into employee complaints because they can face legal consequences (claims of negligence, discrimination) if they do not do so. For example, if an individual alleges discrimination or illegal activity in the workplace and the claims are not investigated, an employer can be potentially held liable by employees affected by the conduct.

The same type of investigation is necessary when dealing with claims of whistleblowing or other alleged inappropriate conduct at work. The point is that Virginia employers will usually conduct a workplace investigation if they receive a complaint. The level of investigation that an employer will conduct depends on the severity of the allegations.

How Virginia Workplace Investigations Start

Employee investigations typically start with an employee complaint alleging that some misconduct has been committed in the workplace. Sometimes, employees can also be investigated for issues occurring outside of work. A complaint usually starts when the employee reports it to Human Resources, a supervisor or other management personnel. Once reported, the misconduct complaint can lead to an investigation. Almost always, in most employment investigations, the employer will hire an outside law firm (or occasionally use internal attorneys) to conduct an employment investigation and will act as the investigator.

Once the investigator is appointed, they will start their investigation.Keep in mind that the employer’s goal in these investigations is to minimize liability for themselves. The investigator is not there to always get to the truth of the matter or to protect your interests. In these types of investigations, complaining employee may also be represented or advised by their own legal counsel.

Investigative Steps

While an investigator may find an individual employee at fault, the investigator usually wants to conclude and document that there was no fault on the part of an employer. When a finding of fault is made, there are more significant problems for an employer. The following steps usually take place in an employer investigation:

  1. An employee files a workplace complaint;
  2. The complaint is reviewed by the employer or Human Resources;
  3. An investigator is usually appointed to investigate the complaint;
  4. The investigator reviews the complaint and plans their investigation;
  5. The investigator reviews any documentation or emails or other evidence available to prepare for interviews;
  6. The investigator interviews the complainant or complainants about the conduct complained of;
  7. The investigator interviews the employees with knowledge of the issues in the complaint;
  8. The investigator interviews the accused employee or employees;
  9. The investigator conducts follow-up interviews of any witnesses as needed;
  10. The investigator reviews all company policies in conjunction with their findings;
  11. The investigator issues a final report with recommendations to an employer;
  12. The employer evaluates the recommendations in the investigative report;
  13. The employer will take action based on the findings in the report; and
  14. The employer’s action can involve disciplinary action against the employee.

Results of Workplace Investigations

Once the employer’s investigation is over, the results and actions taken by the employer can vary. A formal report is usually prepared, along with recommendations on actions that could be taken. The investigation can result in termination or other discipline for an accused employee. The investigation can also vindicate the accused employee. In either event, an employer must be careful to avoid retaliation against a complaining employee, even when their complaint is found to be unjustified. Each investigation is different, and different employers vary in how they handle workplace investigations. The proper handling of an employment investigation can protect employees in the workplace and alsoreduce employer liability. However, it can often be the case that the employer is simply interested in terminating the employee involved instead of fairly resolving disputes. For this reason, it is very important for employees to have their own attorney.

Workplace Reporting Under Virginia Law

While results of workplace investigations in Virginia have not necessarily been a public affair in the past, that is slowly changing. In 2025, Virginia enacted Workplace Violence Reporting in Healthcare Workplaces. While this is just one type of conduct, Virginia may eventually expand this type of reporting to other types of alleged misconduct. This is one example of Virginia starting to require investigations into workplace conduct.

Contact Us

If you are an employee in Virginia and need assistance with an employment investigation or other issue, please contact our office at 703-668-0070 or through our website to schedule a consultation.

VA Clinical Privileges

We defend Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical professionals in clinical privileges cases. Negative clinical privilege decisions impact the ability of medical professionals to practice at the VA. They can also affect professional reputations and career advancement. Furthermore, clinical privileges are essential in order to provide care to veterans. When clinical privileges are revoked or suspended, VA employees face significant professional and personal challenges. VA medical professionals should retain experienced Veterans Affairs employment lawyers when privileging issues arise.

What are Veterans Affairs Clinical Privileges?

VA clinical privileges are given when a VA facility authorizes a medical provider (licensed independent healthcare practitioners or LIPs) to independently (i.e., without supervision or restriction) provide healthcare services on a facility-specific basis. Only providers who are permitted by state law or Federal law or regulation and the VA medical facility through the Medical Staff Bylaws may be privileged to practice independently. Clinical privileges are based on the individual’s clinical competence as determined by peer references, professional experience, health status, education, training, and licensure. Clinical privileges must be VA medical facility-specific, LIP-specific, and within available VA medical facility resources to support the privileges granted.

Grounds for Reduction or Revocation of Clinical Privileges at the VA

There are many reasons why VA clinical privileges can be lost. The privilege review process is governed by specific VA guidelines. These guidelines protect the medical provider’s rights. Generally, if privileges are being reduced or revoked as an adverse action, the action is being taken based on allegations of substandard care, professional misconduct, or professional incompetence.

VA Privileging Oversight

There are two common ways in which the VA exercises oversight over providers for the purposes of privileging: Focused Professional Practice Evaluations (FPPEs) and Ongoing Professional Practice Evaluations (OPPEs).

Focused Professional Practice Evaluations (FPPE)

An FPPE is an oversight process where the respective clinical service chief and the Executive Committee of the Medical Staff (ECMS) evaluate the competence of a provider. This is done for those who have not yet documented evidence of competently performing the requested privileges at a VA medical facility. FPPEs can also be done for Cause. An FPPE for Cause is a period during which the clinical service chief assesses the provider’s performance. This is to determine if any action should be taken on the provider’s privileges after a clinical concern has been triggered and a FCCR has been conducted. If participating in a FPPE, especially one for Cause, it is important to make sure that VA policies are followed in the process.

The FPPE process may include, but is not limited to, periodic chart review, direct observation, monitoring of diagnostic and treatment techniques, or discussion with other individuals involved in the care of patients. Efforts should be taken to ensure that the medical provider is given a fair and impartial review process.

Ongoing Professional Practice Evaluations (OPPE)

An Ongoing Professional Performance Evaluation (OPPE) is the ongoing monitoring of privileged providers to identify clinical practice issues that impact the quality and safety of care. OPPE applies to all providers who are privileged, including physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and clinical pharmacist practitioners who are on Scopes of Practice.

Responding to a Privileging Action at the VA

If a federal employee at the VA faces a potential or actual loss of clinical privileges, it is essential for them to understand the procedural safeguards in place and their rights to challenge such actions.

1. Initial Notification of Adverse Privileging Action

If the VA proposes to revoke, suspend, or limit a healthcare provider’s clinical privileges, they will be notified in writing. This notification should include the specific reasons for the proposed action, along with any supporting evidence or documentation. The medical provider will receive adequate notice in order to respond to the allegations alleged regarding their performance or conduct.

If the provider responds to the proposed action, the provider’s response is provided to the Facility Director for decision. The Facility Director must make and document a decision on the basis of the record. If the provider disagrees with the Facility Director’s decision, an appeal hearing may be requested. The request for a hearing must be submitted within five workdays after receipt of the decision.

At this stage, a provider may have the opportunity for informal resolution. Informal resolutions with management can address issues before a formal privileging decision is made. If the provider can demonstrate that the concerns are unfounded or can propose corrective actions (such as additional training or peer review), it may be possible to resolve the issue without a formal revocation of privileges.

2. Fair Hearing Panel

If the Facility Director upholds the revocation or reduction of privileges action, the provider may request a Fair Hearing. Once a Fair Hearing is requested by the provider, the Facility Director must appoint a review panel of three professionals within five workdays after receipt of the practitioner’s request for a hearing to conduct a review and hearing. At least two members of the Panel must be members of the same profession. If specialized knowledge is required, at least one member of the Panel must be a member of the same specialty.

The provider will be notified of the time, date, and place of the Fair Haring. Prior to the hearing date, the provider will be offered the opportunity to identify witnesses for the hearing and submit exhibits to be considered during the hearing. During the hearing, the provider has the right to be present for the full proceeding, be represented by legal counsel, and call witnesses.

Upon conclusion of the hearing, within 15 working days, the Panel must complete their review of the case and submit their report to the Facility Director. The Facility Director then has the authority to accept, reject, accept in part, or modify the review panel’s recommendations. The Facility Director must issue a written decision within 10 working days of the date of receiving the Panel’s report. Once the Facility Director makes the final decision to reduce or revoke privileges, this decision can be reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB).

3. Appeal of Final Revocation or Reduction Decision

If the Facility Director issues a final decision reducing or revoking the provider’s privileges, the provider may appeal that decision to a final level of review. This final appeal is submitted to the appropriate VISN Director within five workdays of receipt of the facility Director’s decision. This appeal option will not delay the submission of the NPDB report. If the Facility Director’s decision is overturned on appeal, the report to the NPDB must be withdrawn. Once an appeal is filed at this final level, the VISN Director must provide a written decision, based on the record, within 20 work days after receipt of the practitioner’s appeal. The decision of the VISN Director is not subject to further appeal.

Contact Us

Our Veterans Affairs employment lawyers defend medical professionals in privileging cases. We also represent all federal employee medical providers. If you need legal assistance regarding privileging actions or other VA employment matters, please contact our office at (703) 668-0070 or at www.berrylegal.com to schedule a consultation.

We represent federal, Virginia and Washington, D.C. employees in hostile work environment claims. If you have been mistreated at work, especially in a consistent and/or repetitive manner, you might describe it as a “hostile work environment” based on harassment. But in a legal context, this term has a very specific meaning. Not all difficult or abusive workplace situations are actionable under anti-discrimination laws. If a situation is actionable, you may need to act quickly—especially if you are a federal government employee—in order to preserve your rights and potentially obtain relief. It is therefore particularly important to obtain legal counsel as early as possible in order to determine whether your case meets the relevant criteria to bring legal action. An EEO lawyer can also advise you as to what can be done to pursue the claim based on your type of employment and the facts of the case. Regardless, understanding the type of claim is a good first step.Hostile Work Environment Claims

Basics of a Proper Hostile Work Environment Claim

The federal anti-discrimination laws recognize two basic types of harassment claims, and they are fairly intuitive on a surface level: the harassment is either a pattern of conduct (or other change affecting the  work environment in an ongoing way), or it is a discrete action standing by itself, such as a termination. If it is a pattern of abusive treatment, or an ongoing and harmful changed condition of the employment, it can be called a “hostile work environment,” often shortened to HWE. The idea behind HWE is that even if an employee is not directly fired, demoted, or otherwise subjected to a specific adverse action, the “terms and conditions” of their employment can still be changed—either formally, or informally and thus “constructively”—by a sufficiently substantial alteration to the work environment.

Two Key Components of HWE Claims

There are two key components of a proper HWE claim under federal law. The first component is that you must have been subjected to “unwelcome conduct” that was, or is, “severe or pervasive”—enough for the overall work environment to reasonably considered “hostile or abusive.” The second component, which is not obvious to many people and which is the source of much confusion, is that however the “unwelcome conduct” may be manifested, it must also be based on your membership in a legally protected group.

Protected Groups

Protected groups include race, color, or national origin; religion; sex and/or gender, including related statuses such as pregnancy; age; disability; genetic information; or having engaged in prior “protected” Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) activity such as complaining about discrimination or participating in another’s EEOC complaint adjudication. (Discrimination on the basis of prior protected activity is called retaliation or reprisal). Note that this is at the federal level. States may add their own protected groups under their own anti-discrimination laws, but you can’t use state-specific additions to that list if you pursue your case via the federal EEO complaint process. For example, Virginia law protects against discrimination on the basis of marital status or military veteran status; at the federal level, you might have to make a marital status claim using a sex- or gender-based argument, and you would have to potentially pursue the veteran discrimination claim under the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA). USERRA is a separate statute with a separate complaint and adjudication process. You would have to pursue state-level anti-discrimination processes to use the “extra” protected statuses, and the efficacy of those processes can vary substantially by state.

Nexus Requirement

The second component of tying the HWE to a protected status is critical. Absent this “nexus” component, a claim of harassment or HWE will not survive scrutiny under the federal EEO process. That means that abusive work environments which are not based on any of the protected statuses cannot properly be claimed as a “hostile work environment” under these workplace laws, even if they are based on, e.g., intense personal animus or egregiously targeted and arbitrary adverse action. While such situations could be remediable via other processes, such as the Office of Special Counsel (OSC) if you are a federal employee, or via other state protections, it is important to keep in mind that private companies generally enjoy “at will” employment protections. This means they are allowed to fire or otherwise take adverse action against an employee for any reason or even no reason, as long as it is not a discriminatory reason based on these protected statuses. And for federal agencies, arbitrary or otherwise unsupported personnel action could be appealable to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) or reported to OSC, but it is not independently an EEO claim.

Subjective Versus Objective HWE

The EEOC necessarily follows Supreme Court precedent regarding these legal issues. In 1993, the Supreme Court laid out a framework for HWE claims, including with the “severe or pervasive” standard. In that same seminal case, Harris v. Forklift Systems, Inc., the Court also imposed a two-pronged standard for deciding when a work environment is sufficiently “hostile:” it must be both subjectively hostile and objectively hostile.

Objective Hostility

Objective hostility uses the classic legal hypothetical of “reasonableness:” would a “reasonable person” find the work environment objectively hostile or abusive? If not, the claim may not be actionable regardless of what the employee subjectively believes. Because this determination is not made by a complainant themselves, it is worth considering whether a neutral decisionmaker (i.e., a judge or jury) is likely to find that an average, rational person in the employee’s position would find the work environment hostile and/or abusive.

Subjective Hostility

Subjective hostility means that the employee must subjectively believe and perceive the workplace to be hostile and abusive before a HWE claim is valid. This may seem silly—why would somebody claim HWE if they don’t personally consider it hostile or abusive?—but that is the point here: you cannot claim HWE if you don’t personally find the environment to be hostile or abusive, even if a reasonable person would and the only reason you don’t is because you don’t mind it. In other words, you cannot receive a windfall just from being willing to put up with something that a hypothetical “reasonable” employee would find to be objectively hostile.

Together, this means that an unreasonably sensitive person cannot claim HWE over a situation where a reasonable person would not mind, and likewise, an especially stoic person cannot claim HWE without actually perceiving the hostility or abuse as harmful to themselves or their employment. Both subjective and objective hostility must be present.

Further Considerations

Alongside satisfying the “severe or pervasive” standard, demonstrating both subjective and objective hostility, and showing how the problematic actions were based on or motivated by one or more protected statuses, HWE cases often involve even more granular analyses. For example, was the conduct “unwelcome?” How should this be argued in a case with a wide range of allegedly discriminatory and harassing conduct? What if a separate incident is also part of a broader pattern? These issues can get complicated very quickly, which is why experienced representation can be an especially beneficial asset in pursuing a HWE claim.

Contact Us

Although the umbrella concept of “harassment” can include HWE and “regular,” perhaps more isolated harassing conduct by an employer, there are various stages of the EEOC complaint, investigation, and adjudication processes during which presenting the claims properly can be critically important. Even if a mistake can be rectified later in terms of a claim’s phrasing, a complainant misunderstanding and mis-alleging an EEO-related harassment claim can cause problems with how the complaint is processed, investigated, and ultimately adjudicated. As a result, the distinctions between HWE and “other” harassment are helpful to know from the very beginning, and knowledgeable legal counsel can help tailor how your claims are presented in order to achieve the best possible outcome for your case.If you are seeking representation before the EEOC, you can contact us via our website, www.berrylegal.com, or by phone at (703) 668-0070, to arrange for an individual consultation.

security clearance polygraphWe defend and advise government contractors, military personnel, and federal employees who have polygraph examination issues. We do this as part of our security clearance practice. The polygraph examination is a central part of the security clearance process for many employees, depending on their required level of access. For certain federal agencies and clearances, like for sensitive compartmented information (SCI) access, many federal agencies require a polygraph examination. Many clients come to us when they have failed a polygraph examination. They also consult with us when they are facing the decision to make certain disclosures in connection with a polygraph examination or discontinue the process. Additionally, clients meet with us when polygraph examination issues result in a Statement of Reasons.

What is a Polygraph?

The polygraph is a machine designed to detect and record changes in physiological characteristics, such as an individual’s pulse and breathing rates. Some people also refer to it as a lie detector. The exam measures these physiological responses while the individual answers a series of questions. The goal of the polygraph is to attempt to determine whether the individual is being truthful, particularly about issues that could pose national security risks. These risks can include such issues as foreign connections, drug use, financial debts, or criminal activity. The exam is usually administered at the federal agency where you are seeking security access. The exam will then be given by an experienced polygraph examiner. Depending on the type of polygraph examination, the testing session could last 2 to 7 hours.

When is the Polygraph Exam Used?

Polygraph tests are typically used during the background investigation process for higher-level security clearances.They are discussed in Security Executive Agent Directive 2 and DOD Instruction 5210.91. In some polygraphs, the examiner asks a series of yes-or-no questions related to national security concerns, such as whether the applicant has committed espionage or had unauthorized contact with foreign nationals. Additional government guidance on the use of polygraphs within the Intelligence Community (IC) is provided in ICPG 704.6. The exam is meant to be one of many tools in determining a person’s reliability and trustworthiness. While polygraphs are not foolproof and can be influenced by a variety of factors — such as nervousness, medical conditions, or even the examiner’s approach — the results can have a significant impact on the outcome of a clearance investigation. Additionally, the exam process itself may lead to other security disclosures outside of the testing phase. A failed polygraph, however, does not automatically result in disqualification, but it is a potential red flag that must be considered and addressed.

Polygraph Exam Failures During Clearance Investigations

If you fail a polygraph examination, it is important to understand that this does not necessarily mean the end of your security clearance process. The next step typically involves a follow-up interview with the agency conducting the investigation, where you may be asked to discuss issues related to the results of the polygraph. During this interview, it is crucial to be honest, calm, and cooperative. Some applicants may find themselves in a situation where they fail the polygraph, either due to physiological reasons, anxiety, or other factors. This is fairly common. Understanding how to handle this outcome is essential for safeguarding your clearance prospects. We represent individuals in polygraph and security clearance matters.

In many cases, polygraph results may be inconclusive or misinterpreted, and further clarification or re-testing might be necessary. If the failure is related to a specific issue, such as a misunderstanding or anxiety, providing evidence or context may help clear up any doubts. However, if there is a legitimate concern — such as involvement in illegal activities or a failure to disclose critical information during the background check — the results could jeopardize your eligibility for a security clearance. If criminal issues come up, it is important to discuss these with counsel to see if the continued polygraph examination process is in your best interests. Some polygraph disclosures can lead to criminal concerns.

Additional Polygraph Examinations

If you are unable to pass a polygraph examination, you should consider requesting a second (or third) examination, especially if you believe that anxiety or other non-deceptive factors have affected the results. In some cases, it has taken some individuals 4 or 5 polygraph examinations to pass. You may also want to consult with a security clearance lawyer with expertise in polygraph examinations who can help you understand the security clearance process.

If there are unique issues that led to the failure — such as a past criminal act or undisclosed financial problems — you must be prepared to address these concerns in a transparent and honest manner. Failure to do so could be interpreted as a lack of trustworthiness, which could ultimately harm your clearance prospects. In some cases involving criminal issues, legal advice about whether to continue in the process is crucial. It is critical to maintain a high level of honesty and transparency throughout the polygraph process. Review your background information carefully if there are potential security concerns at issue. If you are particularly concerned about the polygraph examination process, consider speaking with a security clearance lawyer in advance, who can advise you on legal issues that could come up

Additional Considerations

A failed polygraph for a security clearance is a serious issue, but it does not necessarily spell the end of your clearance application. Keep in mind that when important issues come up during a polygraph examination, an individual, depending on the agent can request to have counsel nearby or observing the process. By understanding the polygraph process, being prepared to address any concerns in the aftermath, and seeking professional advice when necessary, you can increase your chances of successfully navigating this challenge. The key to handling a polygraph failure is to remain honest, transparent, and cooperative throughout the process. With the right approach, you may still be able to resolve any issues and move forward in the security clearance process.

Contact Us

Our security clearance lawyers represent and advise individuals in polygraph and security clearance matters. If you need legal assistance, please contact our office at (703) 668-0070 or at www.berrylegal.com to schedule a consultation.

MSPB Restores 6 Federal Employees to Employment for Now

The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) ruled favorably yesterday for terminated probationary federal employees. The ruling was significant as it could help other federal employees terminated while on probation. Terminated probationary employees should seek federal Probationary Period for Federal Employeesemployment counsel to preserve their rights.

Probationary Federal Employees

Most federal employees begin their federal employment in a probationary status that lasts one year before they are converted to permanent employees. Usually, there is a narrow basis on which to challenge federal probationary period appeals. During this probationary period, federal agencies can terminate them without much effort and for practically any reason.

Probationary Period Termination Appeals

Probationary employees still have the right to challenge their terminations based on partisan political or marital statusdiscrimination at the MSPB. Additionally, probationary employees can file appeals through the Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) complaint process for discrimination or at the Office of Special Counsel (OSC).

Government Efforts to Fire Probationary Federal Employees

As most federal employees know, the government started firing probationary employees over the last 2 weeks. This resulted from a January 20, 2025 memorandum issued by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) seeking lists of all federal agency probationary employees employed. The number of terminations was massive in scope and exact numbers are unavailable right now. In addition, there are still probationary employes on the job that could be subject to termination who have not been terminated yet. Best estimates put the number of affected employees at approximately 220,000. Furthermore, some probationary employees have already filed appeals with the OSC or MSPB, which are likely pending review. In a case handed down last night, the MSPB stayed the probationary terminations of six employees based on the legal arguments made by the OSC.

How did the OSC get Involved, and What did they Argue?

Several federal employees filed a complaint about their probationary terminations with the OSC. The OSC reviewed their cases and agreed. They filed cases with the MSPB for six federal employees fired in their probationary periods. The OSC requested a stay of the terminations and asked that the government delay them because it appeared that the government had violated federal law. Specifically, the OSC alleged that the government was engaged in prohibited personnel practices under the U.S. Code. The MPSB opinion listed the OSC arguments:

“[The] OSC states that the personnel actions at issue, i.e., the probationary terminations, violate the following laws and regulations governing RIFs and probationary terminations: (1) 5 U.S.C. § 3502; (2) 5 C.F.R. part 351; and (3) 5 C.F.R. § 315.801 et seq. SRF, Tab 1 at 12-13. OSC asserts that the identified statute and regulations concern five of the nine merit system principles.” MSPB Opinion, page 4.

OSC Argued Five Key Points

The OSC argued that the government disregarded 5 prohibited personnel practices from the U.S. Code, including:

 Recruitment should be from qualified individuals from appropriate sources in an endeavor to achieve a work force from all segments of society, and selection and advancement should be determined solely on the basis of relative ability, knowledge, and skills, after fair and open competition which assures that all receive equal opportunity.

 All employees and applicants for employment should receive fair and equitable treatment in all aspects of personnel management without regard to political affiliation, race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status, age, or handicapping condition, and with proper regard for their privacy and constitutional rights.

 The Federal work force should be used efficiently and effectively.

 Employees should be retained on the basis of the adequacy of their performance, inadequate performance should be corrected, and employees should be separated who cannot or will not improve their performance to meet required standards.

 Employees should be—

(A) protected against arbitrary action, personal favoritism, or coercion for partisan political purposes.”

MSPB Opinion, page 5.

One of the major arguments that the OSC made was that the government attempted to conduct a Reduction-in-Force without providing probationary employees their rights and due process. The OSC made other arguments as well. The MSPB reviewed the OSC request to stay the six probationary terminations and approved it. The MSPB Decision is listed here. The MSPB ordered that the six employees be returned to their positions for now. The stay is expected to last at least 45 days and perhaps a lot longer.

What are the Next Steps for Probationary Employees?

Since the OSC received a stay of probationary employee removals from the MSPB, federal employees now seem to have a better chance of appealing their blanket terminations. Indeed, given the MSPB ruling, many federal probationary employees will argue that they were not provided RIF rights either. Many may also argue, given the public statements made, that the terminations were the result of political discrimination. There may be other legal arguments made that have not been focused on yet.

Strategy Considerations for Probationary Employees?

We have been advising probationary federal employees that if they are terminated, they should consider appealing to the MSPB or OSC, depending on their situation. The process may not be fast, given that the OSC case is in litigation, but you could lose your right to challenge the termination if you wait beyond 30 days to file with the MSPB. The best advice is to seek legal counsel and ensure you preserve your rights in the best manner possible.

Contact Us

If you are a federal probationary employee in need of legal assistance, please call our office at (703) 668-0070 or through our website. Our lawyers represent federal employees nationwide before their federal agencies, the MSPB and other forums.

Social Media Use by Federal Employees

For the past 7-10 years, we have seen social networking issues continue to arise in our representation of federal employees in the federal workplace. The bottom line is that it general makes sense to avoid using social media in the federal workplace. Numerous issues keep arising with federal Social Media Federal Employeeemployees being subject to discipline or even removal for use of social media. We frequently represent federal employees accused of misconduct involving social media in the federal workplace. Some tips and thoughts follow.

Pitfalls of Social Media Use in the Federal Workplace

Federal agencies use information posted on Facebook, X, Instagram, Linked In and other social networking sites when they discipline federal employees. Many federal employees have had to appeal these issues to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) when they receive serious discipline or removal.

Anything that is posted on a social networking site like Facebook or X can potentially be brought back into the federal workplace. Some federal agencies have removed federal employees for their use of social media. Delfora v. Dep’t of Navy, 2024 MSPB LEXIS 4141 (July 15, 2024) (Appellant removed, in part, for posting an article on workplace violence on social media; Vidal v. Army, 2011 MSPB Lexis 4788 (Aug. 5, 2011) (Agency removed employee because of alleged anxiety producing comment on Facebook that was reported at work).

Other Social Media Cases of Concern

Other federal agencies have also attempted to discipline federal employees where they have called in sick, but then used posted information on social networking sites to show that the employee was untruthful in using sick leave.  Hunter v. Dep’t of Navy, 2011 MSPB Lexis 3159 (May 11, 2011) (involving allegation that the appellant had called in sick to watch the Superbowl but had posted information on Facebook that he was not really sick).

Other issues that seem to be developing where Federal employees are found to have posted comments to social networking websites while at work (on duty). Sometimes, these have resulted in charges that the federal employee has been compensated for person time spent on social media. All sorts of potential issues could develop in such a situation. If an agency is looking to discipline a federal employee, they could potentially charge them for “time card” issues alleging that they were receiving pay but not actually working or perhaps for neglecting their duties while they were on Facebook, X, etc.

The Use of Facebook, X, Instagram and Other Social Networking Websites at Work

Typically, the use of Facebook and other social media websites by federal human resources officials and supervisors at federal agencies has not been in the form of direct monitoring (which would be problematic and potentially illegal). However, other federal employees or supervisors have reported the social media content of other employees to Human Resources personnel in the past. As you see the real issue that has developed in the context of federal employment is that other co-workers often times print out the postings made by other federal employees and then report them.

Sometimes these individuals, who are “friends,” “followers” or connections on social networking sites allege that the federal employee involved has posted inappropriate, discriminatory or even harassing comments.  The most likely situation would be where a federal employee posts inappropriate or angry comments about their supervisor and another co-worker prints out the comments and brings them into work.

Once this information is in the hands of the federal agency, often times they can find a legitimate connection to incorporate the issue into a disciplinary or even a removal action. While there is a right to some privacy and even the First Amendment, often times a connection (or nexus) to the Federal workplace can be found to enable the Federal agency involved to take disciplinary action related to off duty activities.  The MSPB and the Federal Circuit have generally held that off duty activities can be subject to discipline where it could cause the public or co-workers, to question or lose confidence in the Federal agency involved. See Stump v. Department of Transportation, 761 F.2d 680, 681-82 (Fed. Cir. 1985).

Know your Agency’s Rules on the Use of Government Internet or Computers

Lastly, it is important to take a look at your agency’s policy on use of government internet or computers. Often, many policies will restrict social media usage. One example is from the Department of Commerce and can be found here.

Contact Us

Be careful what you post on social networking sites. Also, be very careful about sharing access to your social networking sites with others at work in the federal workplace.  If a federal employee or supervisor finds themselves in a difficult situation as a result of using social networking websites, they should contact an attorney familiar with these types of Federal employee issues to advise them in how to best to defend against disciplinary investigations or disciplinary actions that result. We can be contacted for possible representation in these cases.

We often meet with civilian federal employees, military personnel and government contractors nationwide facing potential or actual security clearance issues. Many of the potential clients we meet with ask us what security clearance lawyers do and why they may need to hire one. ManyHiring a security clearance lawyer individuals also ask what the appropriate time is in which to hire one. The usual answer we give is that it is best to do so very early in the process. We feel that the earlier in the process a person obtains legal advice about their security clearance concerns, if potential issues exist, the better they increase the odds of a successful outcome.

Obtain Legal Advice Early

As I mentioned above, it is extremely important that individuals with potential security issues consult with experienced security clearance counsel as soon as possible. In our experience, the earlier that an individual with security concerns or potential security concerns consults with a knowledgeable security clearance lawyer, the better the chances are to avert a potential negative outcome.  We also find that it is less expensive to address a problem early before it gets more difficult to defend or respond to. One of the most frustrating issues that we run across in representing employees with security clearance issues is when they come to us too late to avert a negative outcome that might have otherwise been avoided.

What Does a Security Clearance Lawyer Do?

I am often asked the question of just how an attorney can assist a person in the security clearance process.  The answer is that there are many ways that an experienced lawyer in security clearance law can help when there are security concerns.  A lawyer experienced in the security clearance process can advise an individual before a security clearance problem develops. We have found that most individuals have a good sense as to whether or not they may have a security concern (e.g. a recent arrest, drug use, financial issues) as they apply for positions or when they fill out security clearance forms like the e-QIP, eApp, SF-86 and/or different versions of the SF-85. Sometimes individuals don’t weigh (or really plan out) how much a potential security issue can affect their ability to obtain a clearance. Having a security clearance lawyer advise a person about the process can be invaluable.

Consulting Before the Clearance Review Process Begins

When an individual understands that they may have a security concern, consulting with a security clearance attorney can help them get ahead of potential security clearance concerns. One of the major issues that we see in the clearance process is when an individual comes to us too late in the process to alter a negative clearance outcome. We have seen individuals who could have likely obtained or retained their security clearances, but did not seek legal advice early enough in the process to avoid a pitfall which ultimately caused the loss of the clearance.

Sometimes, individuals have had financial issues which could have been easily mitigated, but the person did not realize what type of information was needed for their response. They then receive a denial and are left with fewer options in the appeals process. On other occasions, individuals have security concerns but have not listed them because they did not feel they were important or that it was debatable to them whether they applied (i.e. counseling or an employment termination).  Getting early legal advice on these issues (and being straightforward in the process) is often the key to success.

When consulting with an individual, a security clearance attorney can get a pretty good idea as to the seriousness of the security concerns at issue and what level of risk is involved in the person applying for a security clearance. In the case of a person who has the option to apply for a security clearance, but more time might be needed to mitigate security concerns we can help the person avoid the potential of a denial by advising them to take more time before applying. In this type of situation, we sometimes advise individuals to wait a year (or the appropriate timeframe) before applying for a position that requires a security clearance.  It is also not uncommon that a security clearance lawyer can anticipate a serious issue with someone obtaining a security clearance, i.e. recent criminal charges, which helps them avoid the embarrassment of applying for a position that they may get only to be removed later when their clearance is not approved. A security clearance attorney can also help to put an applicant’s mind at ease if the risk they are concerned about is not as problematic as it seems.

Review of Accuracy of Security Clearance Forms

Additionally, a security clearance attorney can review an individual’s security clearance / federal employment forms (SF-86, SF-85, SF-85p, OF-306) to ensure that they are as accurate and responsive as possible. It is very important to disclose all potential information, accurately, on these forms. Not doing so can form the basis for a denial based on a lack of candor or alleged falsification. We often see issues arise from the unintentional omission of key information that may not seem to be important (or remembered) at the time the security clearance forms were prepared but later becomes the basis of a clearance denial. The most usual culprit in this type of situation is that the individual was not trying to be dishonest but did not put the time and thought that these forms require and simply made a mistake.

Furthermore, while rare, issues disclosed can lead to criminal concerns. As a result, it can sometimes be important to discuss potential criminal disclosures in advance. It is not often the case that disclosures about potential criminal issues become the basis for a criminal prosecution, but sometimes these questions need to be asked before completing a clearance submission. In other words, if an individual has a potential security concern it is key to get legal advice as early in the process as possible. Waiting to get advice after the security clearance process has unfolded can significantly diminish the chances of success for individuals with security concerns.

Consulting/Representation once the Security Clearance Process Begins

It is also important to have the guidance of a security clearance attorney when the security clearance process has begun. The security clearance forms in such a case have been submitted and the individual has potential security concerns, i.e. a record of arrests or financial issues and are in the process of being scheduled for an investigative interview. In such a situation, it is important to go over the areas of concern with a client that are likely to come up in the interview with a security clearance attorney. There are often ways of responding during an interview that can clear up any misperceptions by the investigator or perhaps mitigate these concerns in advance.

Again, it is extremely important to be honest and accurate during the clearance interview process and sometimes to even disclose concerns before the interview begins in certain cases. An experienced security clearance lawyer can help advise an individual about these issues and disclosures before they are interviewed.  We often review such concerns with clients in advance of security clearance interviews and help them in explaining the security concerns, in advance, so that all goes as smoothly as possible during the interview or re-interview process.

Legal Representation in Clearance Denials or Proposed Denials

An individual will definitely need a security clearance attorney if they receive a denial or proposed denial of their security clearance. Each federal agency is different and there are different security clearance processes for each federal agency. This causes some confusion with clients. The security clearance system has been left to each federal agency under existing rules. The type of response needed will also differ based upon which federal agency is processing the clearance review.

This is the case even though all federal agencies fall under the same Executive Order 12968.  It is also important that the individual consult with experienced counsel where they can explain any issues that individual federal agencies are particularly sensitive to. For instance, the FBI is more sensitive to prior drug use by applicants or employees and many intelligence agencies are sensitive to the misuse or careless handling of classified or otherwise sensitive information. In other words, each federal agency has slightly different views depending on the type of security concerns involved.

Response to Security Concerns

In general, each federal agency usually has a written and personal appearance response stage for those who need to appeal a denial or proposed denial in the security clearance appeals process. While different, each federal agency will provide some form of a Statement of Reasons (SOR) or notice which explains the nature of the security concern at issue.  Furthermore, while the procedures and vantage points of a security clearance appeal are different between agencies, they follow the guidelines issues by the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), which became effective June 8, 2017.  The DNI issued new adjudicative guidelines entitled Security Executive Agency Directive 4 (SEAD 4) which provides a list of potential security concerns and mitigation.  A copy of SEAD 4 is provided here. A security clearance lawyer will be versed in the latest regulations governing such appeals (both federal government-wide and federal agency-specific) before the individual agency involved and will be able to assist a person in navigating the type of appeal to present.

Written Response Stage

The typical first step in the security clearance process is to provide a written response to the security concerns to the clearance review authority. To do so, an experienced security clearance attorney will obtain a complete fact set from the individual regarding the security concerns at issue and work to determine the best possible methods of rebutting and/or mitigating these security concerns. There is also a whole-person concept evaluation, which counsel can assist with by explaining the positive attributes about the individual’s character and/or background which can also help to mitigate clearance issues. To this end, we also often ask a potential client about their employment performance, community involvement and/or whether or not they can obtain letters of recommendation or reference for use in mitigation.

The written response usually takes the form of a written submission by counsel, exhibits, and attaches an affidavit or sworn declaration.  It is not uncommon for such responses to be 10 to 70 pages in length, with exhibits.  The length of a submission depends on the security concerns at issue and the type of mitigating documents that are available for a case.

Personal Appearance or Oral Response Stage

While it is very important to provide a detailed written response to security clearance issues, it is even more important to present a thorough oral presentation where the opportunity to do so arises.  We almost always recommend that an individual elect a hearing or personal appearance in security clearance cases. Again, the format for these presentations differ. Some federal agencies conduct formal hearings with an administrative judge (Department of Defense, Department of Energy) and other agencies have appeals panels (National Security Agency, Central Intelligence Agency) staffed by agency employees which hear each case. Additionally, other federal agencies appoint one adjudicator to hear informal appeals. To this end, each federal agency is different.

Regardless of format, a security clearance lawyer will prepare a client for their testimony and will prepare witnesses for their supporting testimony and potential cross-examination or questioning (where the forum permits in person witnesses). It is also important to note that in many forums the government will be represented by their own attorney and it is very important for an individual to have their own counsel in the proceedings.  We find that personal appearances have the greatest potential to reverse negative findings. The ultimate appeals officer, whether it is an administrative judge, an appeals panel or a hearing officer often finds that the most important evidence in a case is to directly hear from the individual involved.  A security clearance attorney will prepare a client for the questions that may arise and the best manner in which to rebut or mitigate them.

Contact Us

When a federal employee, military personnel or government contractor is facing security clearance concerns it is important to obtain legal advice and legal representation early in the process. Our law firm advises individuals in the security clearance process. We can be contacted at www.berrylegal.com or by telephone at (703) 668-0070.

If you wish to explore legal representation, please call our office or use this form to inquire about our consultation process.

Call Us Today!703-668-0070

Office Location

Plaza America
11700 Plaza America Drive
Suite 305
Reston, VA 20190

Get Directions

Follow Us

  • twitter