Upgrading a Security Clearance
Security clearance upgrades raise potential issues for many clearance holders. For many federal employees, military members, and government contractors, moving from a Secret Clearance to a Top Secret (TS) or Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) clearance can lead to higher-paying positions and more career growth. But with these opportunities comes deeper scrutiny when it comes time for adjudication.
A clearance upgrade is not automatic, and even small issues can slow down the process or create avoidable problems potentially affecting all of your security clearances. The following are some practical tips to consider as you seek a clearance upgrade.
Enhanced Investigations Occur When Upgrading to a TS or SCI Clearance
While all security clearances require an investigation, they get more rigorous as the clearance level gets higher. A TS clearance involves a much more in-depth background investigation than a Secret-level clearance does. A TS investigation includes more extensive checks into finances, foreign contacts, travel, and personal conduct. If your position requires SCI access, expect additional steps, which may include a polygraph examination and a separate vetting process depending on the agency involved. In my experience, the jump to SCI is more rigorous than moving to a TS from a Secret-level clearance.
Submission of a New SF-86 Required
In preparing for the upgrade, you should review and update your SF-86/eQIP/eApp. The Standard Form 86 (SF-86) is the foundation of your entire clearance investigation. When upgrading your clearance, you will likely be required to submit a new or updated version of the form. Mistakes on this form are one of the most common causes of delays.
Some frequent security issues include:
- Forgetting to list foreign travel, relatives, or contacts,
- Omitting financial debts or delinquencies,
- Failing to disclose past drug use or arrests,
- Previous disclosures missing from prior SF-86 forms,
- Leaving out previous addresses, employers, or supervisors.
A SF-86 is a legal document. Omissions, even accidental, can raise concerns about truthfulness that are harder to mitigate than the underlying issue. One of the most frequent issues we run across is where a clearance holder simply repeats the same information from an older SF-86 without realizing that changes have occurred since the last investigation.
Address Any Financial or Foreign Influence Issues Early
Before upgrading, attempt to anticipate any new security concerns that could come up and try to resolve or mitigate them in advance. Two of the most common reasons for clearance delays or denials are: (1) Guideline F (Financial Considerations); and (2) Guideline B (Foreign Influence). It is important to address these two issues fully and directly if they arise.
If you have family overseas, dual citizenship concerns, or foreign assets, be upfront and prepared to demonstrate continued loyalty to the United States and to demonstrate that you are not subject to undue foreign influence. Additionally, if you have had credit problems, debt collection accounts, or a history of bankruptcy, gather documentation showing that you have resolved or are responsibly managing your finances.
These issues will almost always come up in an upgrade investigation, and it is important to get ahead of them where possible.
More Intensive Interview and Possible Polygraph Process
As mentioned above, during a TS investigation you will be interviewed by an investigator who will review your SF-86, clarify information, and discuss any potential issues. If SCI access is required, you may also undergo a counterintelligence or lifestyle polygraph. These examinations assess honesty and identify potential security vulnerabilities. Be honest, calm, and forthcoming; investigators are typically more concerned about dishonesty than about conduct that occurred years ago.
Importance of Avoiding New Security Issues During Investigation
Your clearance upgrade is not complete when you submit your SF-86. You remain under review for the upgrade until adjudication is complete. If new issues arise you may have to complete an SF-86C or other agency-specific paperwork.
During this time, avoid creating new potential security concerns such as:
- Taking on significant debt,
- Using illegal drugs (marijuana) even in states where they are “legal” under state law,
- Getting involved in criminal or domestic disputes,
- Failing to report foreign travel or contacts.
Encountering new security concerns while your upgrade is processing can significantly delay or impede your investigation so do your best to avoid any new issues.
Clearance Upgrade Rights if Issues Arise
If the agency has unresolved concerns, you may receive a Statement of Reasons (SOR) or a Letter of Intent to deny or revoke your clearance (LOI). If this happens, you have the right to respond and appeal. The process varies between federal employees, military members and government contractors. In fact, it is very important that you respond given that adverse issues can affect not only the upgrade but your existing security clearance.
Experienced security clearance counsel can help you prepare a thorough SOR or LOI response which includes mitigating evidence and a detailed rebuttal. Many clearances that initially appear “at risk” are ultimately granted after a well-supported rebuttal and/or a personal appearance.
Continue Good Clearance Habits After Upgrade
Once your TS or SCI clearance is approved, your responsibilities continue. You will remain subject to continuous evaluation, and your agency may still conduct periodic reviews. However, you can relax knowing that the adjudication is complete. If you are upgrading to a TS, you may have to repeat this process again if you later need an SCI.
Contact Us
Upgrading from a Secret to TS or SCI clearance is a significant step for an individual’s career growth. It is crucial to handle the upgrade process with care. If you anticipate possible security concerns, financial, foreign, or otherwise, address them early and seek the assistance of a security clearance lawyer. Please contact us here or at (703) 668-0070 if you need any security clearance assistance.
